How This Horror Movie Perfected Alternate Endings Before ‘Clue’

 

Long before the cult classic Clue entertained audiences with multiple endings, a master showman executed the concept with a brilliantly cruel twist. In 1961, legendary director William Castle released Mr. Sardonicus, a gothic horror film that featured an audacious “Punishment Poll” where audiences could vote on the villain’s fate. This groundbreaking gimmick, however, was an elaborate illusion, cementing Castle’s reputation as the king of cinematic spectacle.

The Master of Gimmicks and His Macabre Tale

William Castle was a filmmaker who believed the movie-going experience should be an event. His career was built on sensational promotional tactics that turned screenings into must-see attractions. Mr. Sardonicus was a perfect vehicle for his style. The film tells the story of a Baron, played by Guy Rolfe, who is cursed with a permanent, grotesque grin after digging up his father’s grave. He lures a London doctor to his castle in a desperate attempt to cure his horrifying condition, leading to a tense and melodramatic tale of morality and revenge.

Castle, never one for subtlety, knew the film needed an extra hook. He devised the “Punishment Poll,” a system where theater patrons were given cards with a thumbs-up or thumbs-down side. As documented in sources like the American Film Institute catalog, Castle would appear on screen before the finale, asking the audience to vote on whether the villainous Baron deserved mercy or punishment. This interactive element made every viewer a participant in the story’s outcome, a novel concept for its time.

The Punishment Poll’s Deceptive Brilliance

The genius—and deception—of the Punishment Poll was that the audience’s choice never actually mattered. Historical accounts and industry reports confirm that only one ending was ever filmed: the bleak, punitive conclusion where Baron Sardonicus is abandoned, left mute and paralyzed with his monstrous grin forever frozen. Castle himself later admitted in his autobiography that the vote was a fantastic sham, a placebo designed to maximize audience engagement.

This trick worked perfectly. Moviegoers of the era, eager for a unique experience, flocked to theaters believing they held the power of judgment. The gimmick played on the universal desire to see villainy receive its just deserts, ensuring that the “punishment” vote would always win. Unlike Clue, whose multiple endings confused 1985 audiences and contributed to its initial box office struggle, Castle’s concept was simple, theatrical, and brilliantly marketed. It transformed the film from a simple chiller into a memorable event, outperforming its budget and becoming a staple of classic horror.

A Lasting Legacy of Theatrical Magic

The legacy of Mr. Sardonicus and William Castle’s gimmicks endures as a testament to a bygone era of showmanship. In a modern age of digital streaming and standardized cinema, Castle’s efforts to create tangible, shared excitement feel both nostalgic and innovative. His influence is seen in filmmakers like John Waters, who employed similar tactile gimmicks, and in the continued cultural fascination with interactive storytelling.

Hallmark Channel Original Movies: Leading the Family Entertainment Revolution

William Castle’s Mr. Sardonicus remains a fascinating footnote in cinema history, demonstrating that sometimes the greatest magic lies not in the story on the screen, but in the experience crafted around it. This classic film, a precursor to all interactive media, is available for free on YouTube, offering a chilling glimpse into the past where a director’s wildest ideas could truly come to life.

---

Must Know

What was the William Castle Mr. Sardonicus Punishment Poll?
The Punishment Poll was an audience participation gimmick for the 1961 film Mr. Sardonicus. Moviegoers were given cards to vote thumbs-up or thumbs-down to decide if the villain should be shown mercy or punished. It was a revolutionary marketing tactic created by director William Castle.

Did the audience vote actually change the ending of Mr. Sardonicus?
No, it did not. Despite the compelling illusion of choice, director William Castle confirmed that only one ending was ever filmed—the punishment ending. The vote was a clever placebo designed to enhance audience engagement and create a unique theatrical event.

How did Mr. Sardonicus perform compared to the movie Clue?
While both films used alternate endings, Mr. Sardonicus was considered a successful gimmick for its time that drew audiences in. Conversely, Clue (1985) was initially a box office disappointment, partly because its multiple endings confused viewers and were poorly marketed.

Where can you watch Mr. Sardonicus today?
The film is considered a public domain title. It is widely accessible and can be streamed for free on various platforms, including YouTube, allowing new generations to experience William Castle’s unique brand of horror showmanship.

What other gimmicks did William Castle use?
William Castle was famous for his gimmicks. For The Tingler (1959), he installed vibrating devices in theater seats. For House on Haunted Hill (1959), he had a plastic skeleton fly over the audience. Each gimmick was designed to make seeing his films an unforgettable event.

Who was the actor who played Mr. Sardonicus?
The role of the tormented Baron Sardonicus was played by British actor Guy Rolfe. His performance, hidden behind a chilling mask of a frozen grin, is a central pillar of the film’s enduring gothic appeal.