All’s Fair Review: Kim Kardashian’s Legal Drama Opens with a Glossy but Uneven Pilot

Ryan Murphy’s new legal drama All’s Fair premiered with its pilot episode on November 4, 2025, introducing a powerful trio of women running a high-end, female-led law firm in Los Angeles. The show stars Kim Kardashian as Allura Grant, Naomi Watts as Liberty Ronson, and Niecy Nash as Emerald Greene — three lawyers fighting for women’s justice in a world of power, wealth, and betrayal.

The episode mixes glamour with legal melodrama, showcasing extravagant lifestyles and emotional confrontations. Yet beneath the luxury lies a messy tone that struggles to balance empowerment with over-the-top storytelling.

All’s Fair Episode 1 Recap: The Beginning of the Empire

The episode opens with Allura and Liberty quitting their male-dominated law firm to start a women-focused practice. With Dina Standish’s guidance and investigator Emerald Greene’s help, they launch a new chapter in their careers. Ten years later, the firm thrives — until old rival Carrington Lane (Sarah Paulson) resurfaces, vowing revenge.

Two high-stakes cases drive the story: a billionaire divorce involving Sheila Baskin and her cosmetics tycoon husband, and a scandal between tech billionaire Lionel Lee and actress Grace Henry. The women navigate prenups, affairs, and emotional manipulation with sharp instincts and courtroom bravado. Liberty’s daring confrontation in New York and Allura’s negotiation tactics highlight the firm’s confidence — until Allura’s own marriage collapses in the final act. The twist ending reveals her husband’s affair with her assistant, Milan, setting up major drama for future episodes.

Kim Kardashian Surprises, but the Script Falters

Kim Kardashian’s casting as Allura Grant sparked controversy, but her performance is surprisingly grounded. She brings poise and understated restraint, channeling her real-life persona into the role of a high-powered divorce attorney. Naomi Watts delivers a more theatrical turn as Liberty, while Niecy Nash’s comedic timing keeps the dialogue lively. Sarah Paulson stands out as Carrington, the unhinged rival who adds bite to the drama.

However, critics argue that All’s Fair leans too heavily on style over substance. The Guardian described the show as “fascinatingly, incomprehensibly, existentially terrible,” citing its awkward dialogue and inconsistent tone. Despite Murphy’s signature production polish, the show’s empowerment message sometimes feels superficial — a mix of luxury branding and moral posturing.

Verdict: Lavish, Entertaining, but Tonally Confused

As a pilot, All’s Fair succeeds in grabbing attention. Its opulent visuals, sharp costuming, and star-studded cast promise a guilty-pleasure watch. Yet, beneath the glamour lies a formulaic script that confuses empowerment with spectacle. The episode delivers intrigue and cliffhangers but leaves viewers questioning whether it aims to be satire, drama, or self-parody.

All’s Fair review: A bold but uneven debut that mixes sharp performances with hollow storytelling. Fans of Ryan Murphy’s glossy drama style will find it visually stunning — others may find it dramatically excessive.

FYI (keeping you in the loop)-

Q1: Who stars in All’s Fair?

The main cast includes Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash, Sarah Paulson, and Glenn Close in a mentor role.

Q2: Where can you watch All’s Fair?

The series is available for streaming on Disney+ starting November 4, 2025.

Q3: What is All’s Fair about?

The show follows three women lawyers who create an all-female law firm representing women in high-profile divorce cases.

Q4: How has All’s Fair been received by critics?

Critics are divided. Some praise its style and cast; others, like The Guardian, called it a “fascinatingly terrible” show.

Q5: Will there be more episodes of All’s Fair?

Yes. Season 1 will continue weekly, with new cases and deeper rivalries unfolding between Allura, Liberty, and Carrington.