Amy Bradley Ransom Demand: Ex-Officer Sought $50,000 in Botched 2000 Deal, Investigator Reveals

A former police officer from Curaçao demanded $50,000 to locate missing American tourist Amy Bradley. Private investigator Jim Carey disclosed the failed 2000 ransom deal on November 14, 2025. The explosive revelation suggests Bradley may have been alive years after her 1998 disappearance from a cruise ship.The Bradley family agreed to the payment and worked with Interpol. Their efforts to secure Amy’s safe return collapsed when the suspect refused anything but cash. This new information, omitted from a recent Netflix documentary, reshapes the 27-year investigation.

The Signed Contract and a Sudden Collapse

In 1999, Herman Goilo contacted the Bradley family. The ex-police clerk claimed he had seen Amy alive on the island of Curaçao. He provided specific, accurate details about her appearance and situation.Goilo insisted he could secure her release for a price. The demanded amount was $50,000. The family, desperate for any lead, took his claim seriously.They immediately involved Interpol. A formal contract for Amy’s safe return was drafted in June 2000. According to NewsNation, Goilo signed the document, agreeing to the terms.The deal fell apart when Interpol agents arrived with a cashier’s check. Goilo refused the check and demanded physical cash. The family could not legally transport that amount of cash, ending the exchange.

New Scrutiny on a Decades-Old Mystery

This revelation confirms someone claimed to know Amy’s location two years after she vanished. It challenges the theory that she accidentally fell overboard. The involvement of a former police official points to potential corruption.The recent Netflix series “Amy Bradley Is Missing” brought the case back into the spotlight. However, Carey states it left out this critical ransom attempt. This omission paints an incomplete picture of the investigation’s history.For the Bradley family, this information renews a painful but persistent hope. A genuine lead existed, backed by an international police agency. The case stalled not from a lack of evidence, but from a broken deal.Carey and his team confronted Goilo again in October 2024. The former clerk allegedly told investigators that Amy was alive as recently as 2016. He described her as a “very different woman,” allegedly struggling with addiction.

Dawn Little Sky, Pioneering Native American Actress and Disney Artist, Dies at 95

The botched ransom deal remains a pivotal, yet largely unknown, chapter in the search for Amy Bradley. It proves that credible offers for her return were made long after she vanished.

Thought you’d like to know

Who is Herman Goilo?

Herman Goilo is a former police clerk from Curaçao. He contacted the Bradley family in 1999, claiming he could locate Amy for $50,000. He signed an Interpol contract in 2000 but later sabotaged the deal.

What was the outcome of the ransom attempt?

The ransom attempt failed when Goilo refused a cashier’s check and demanded physical cash. The Bradley family could not legally bring $50,000 in cash to Curaçao, causing the deal to collapse in June 2000.

Does the FBI still consider Amy Bradley missing?

Yes, the FBI still classifies Amy Bradley as missing and maintains an active page for her. A $25,000 reward is offered for information leading to her recovery.

What was omitted from the Netflix documentary?

The Netflix documentary “Amy Bradley Is Missing” did not feature the detailed account of the 2000 ransom demand. Investigator Jim Carey revealed this information separately in late 2025.

What are the current theories about her disappearance?

Current theories suggest she was a victim of human trafficking. This is supported by alleged sightings and the involvement of individuals connected to criminal networks in the Caribbean.