Apple Slams EU’s “Illogical” Digital Services Act Inquiry, Cites Security Concerns

Apple has formally responded to a European Commission inquiry. The tech giant defended its App Store safety measures. This response came in late 2024. The inquiry questioned Apple’s compliance with the Digital Services Act (DSA).

According to Reuters, the European Commission sought details on App Store fraud prevention. It also asked about policies for protecting minors from harmful content. Apple provided all requested information but strongly criticized the probe’s timing and logic.

A Regulatory Paradox: DSA Scrutiny vs. DMA Mandates

Apple’s letter, written by Vice President of Legal Kyle Andeer, highlighted a major contradiction. He stated the DSA investigation “defies all logic” given the EU’s simultaneous enforcement of the Digital Markets Act (DMA). The DMA forces Apple to allow app sideloading and alternative marketplaces.

Andeer argued this creates a dangerous paradox. One EU law pushes for maximum user protection within the App Store. Another law requires Apple to open iOS to distribution methods that lack those same safeguards. This situation, he wrote, leaves users exposed to higher risks of fraud and scams outside the App Store’s controlled environment.

Broader Impact on Consumer Safety and Market Fairness

This conflict places Apple in a difficult regulatory position. The company must now navigate two sets of EU rules that appear to work against each other. This friction could ultimately impact user security across the European Union. Consumers may face confusing choices between safety and freedom.

For the market, this represents a pivotal moment in tech regulation. The outcome will test how well competing regulatory goals can coexist. It will also shape how large platforms like Apple balance openness with their security responsibilities. The European Commission now faces pressure to clarify its stance.

The core of the dispute is a fundamental clash between regulatory goals. Apple is being asked to both dismantle and reinforce its security walls simultaneously. This Apple EU DSA inquiry reveals the complex challenges of governing today’s digital ecosystems.

Thought you’d like to know

What is the Digital Services Act (DSA)?

The DSA is a European Union regulation. It aims to create a safer online environment for users. The law focuses on combating illegal content and protecting fundamental rights online.

How does the DMA differ from the DSA?

The Digital Markets Act (DMA) targets large “gatekeeper” platforms to ensure fair competition. It mandates features like third-party app stores. The DSA focuses on user safety and content moderation across digital services.

What App Store fraud statistics did Apple share?

Apple reported significant enforcement actions for 2024. The company removed 37,000 apps for fraud. It also rejected 115,000 apps for creating unsafe user experiences.

Why does Apple say the inquiry is illogical?

Apple argues it makes no sense to scrutinize its safety measures while another law forces it to create less secure distribution channels. The company sees these regulatory actions as directly conflicting with each other.

What happens next in this process?

The European Commission will review Apple’s response. It must decide how to reconcile the DSA’s safety goals with the DMA’s competition mandates. This could lead to further legal clarification or new guidance.