Will JJ Garcia Join The Bachelorette? Nikki and Brie Garcia Reveal

The search for the next Bachelorette suitor has taken an unexpected turn. Producers recently approached the brother of WWE stars Nikki and Brie Garcia. They wanted JJ Garcia to join the cast for the new season starring Taylor Frankie Paul.

The Garcia twins revealed this on their SiriusXM podcast, The Nikki and Brie Show. However, they immediately shut down the opportunity. They felt their brother’s wild personality was not suited for the televised dating experiment.

Casting Strategy Revealed Through Rejection

Nikki Garcia provided insight into the show’s new casting direction. She believes producers sought out her brother specifically because he is a single father. “Now you know the people they’re going after, dads that are single,” she stated on the podcast. This suggests a shift in the typical contestant profile.

JJ Garcia is a 39-year-old dad to two daughters. His sisters famously call his uninhibited side “Vacation JJ.” They feared that version would not translate well on national television. Brie Garcia even warned that his antics surpass her own infamous “Brie Mode.”

Taylor Frankie Paul’s Journey Begins Amid Casting Shifts

The new season will feature Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star Taylor Frankie Paul. She has expressed her own shock at being chosen for the leading role. Paul admitted the reality of her situation has not yet sunk in.

She told Alex Cooper on the Call Her Daddy podcast that it will feel real only when the limo arrives. Despite the behind-the-scenes casting drama, fans like Brie Garcia are still planning to tune in. The focus now shifts to Paul’s journey to find love.

The new Bachelorette season highlights a potential new casting strategy, focusing on single fathers and diverse backgrounds. This move could refresh the long-running franchise’s formula for a modern audience.

Dropping this nugget your way

Who is the next Bachelorette?

The next Bachelorette is Taylor Frankie Paul. She is known for her role on the reality show *Secret Lives of Mormon Wives* and is a mother of three.

Why wasn’t JJ Garcia cast on the show?

His sisters, Nikki and Brie Garcia, vetoed the idea. They felt his “Vacation JJ” personality was not a good fit for the televised dating process.

Are any couples from the Bachelor franchise still together?

Yes, several couples are still together. Recent successes include Joey Graziadei and Kelsey Anderson, who are engaged, and Zach Shallcross and Kaity Biggar, who are now married.

What does this say about Bachelorette casting?

The interest in JJ Garcia suggests producers are expanding their search. They appear to be actively looking for single parents and individuals with more established lives.

Did the Garcia sisters approve of the offer?

No, they did not. Nikki and Brie Garcia publicly stated they rejected the offer on their brother’s behalf during an episode of their podcast.