Brian Littrell Sues Neighbor in High-Stakes Florida Beach Access Dispute

Backstreet Boy Brian Littrell is taking his neighbor to court. The singer and his wife, Leighanne, have filed a lawsuit over a bitter property dispute. The conflict centers on their Florida beachfront home in Santa Rosa Beach.

The legal action alleges repeated trespassing and harassment. It marks a dramatic turn for what was meant to be a private family retreat. The case highlights growing tensions over coastal property rights.

Alleged Trespassing and Harassment Detailed in Court Filings

According to the lawsuit, neighbor Carolyn Barrington Hill repeatedly entered their property. She allegedly ignored clear ‘No Trespassing’ signs. The incidents reportedly occurred between April and September 2025.

Court documents claim Hill set up beach furniture on the Littrells’ sand. She is also accused of videotaping the family without their consent. The Littrells state these actions caused them significant emotional distress.

They felt their family’s safety was compromised. This led them to hire private security. The dream of a peaceful oceanfront home had vanished.

Legal Wrangling Over Public vs. Private Beach Rights

The case touches on a complex legal issue in Florida. State law distinguishes between wet sand and dry sand areas. The dry sand area above the high tide line can be privately owned.

However, some local ordinances allow public access. This creates a gray area that often leads to disputes. The Littrells’ attorney, Peter Ticktin, argues they are defending their legal property rights.

Hill has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. She contends the legal claims are insufficient. A hearing on this motion is scheduled for December 11, 2025.

Social Media Amplifies the Coastal Conflict

The dispute has not stayed within the courtroom. Videos of confrontations have spread on social media. An Instagram account called Shoreline Defender has posted several clips.

One video shows Leighanne Littrell in a heated argument with a beachgoer. Brian Littrell is seen silently holding a ‘No Trespassing’ sign. The online circulation has turned a local issue into a public spectacle.

This publicity has influenced public perception of the case. It underscores how quickly private legal matters can become community talking points.

The outcome of Brian Littrell’s lawsuit could set a significant precedent for Florida beach access. This legal battle demonstrates the fierce emotions tied to coastal property lines. The final ruling will have lasting implications for homeowners and beachgoers alike.

Info at your fingertips

What is Brian Littrell suing his neighbor for?

He is suing for alleged trespassing and harassment. The lawsuit claims the neighbor repeatedly entered their private beach area. It also accuses her of videotaping the family without permission.

Where is the Littrells’ Florida property located?

The property is in Santa Rosa Beach, Florida. It is a multi-million dollar oceanfront home. The dispute involves the dry sand area directly in front of their house.

What is the main legal issue in this case?

The core issue is the distinction between public and private beach access in Florida. The law is often unclear about dry sand areas above the high tide line. Local ordinances can further complicate the matter.

Has there been a court hearing yet?

A hearing on the neighbor’s motion to dismiss is set for December 2025. The main lawsuit is still proceeding. No final judgment has been made in the case.

Why is this case getting so much attention?

Brian Littrell’s celebrity status has drawn public interest. The case also touches on a common point of conflict in coastal communities. Social media videos have amplified the dispute significantly.