Brian Littrell Lawsuit: Backstreet Boy Sues Neighbor Over Florida Beach Trespassing

Backstreet Boys star Brian Littrell is taking legal action against his Florida neighbor. He filed a lawsuit over alleged repeated trespassing and harassment at his beachfront home. The case highlights ongoing tensions over private property rights on Florida’s coveted coastline.

According to Reuters, the legal documents were filed in Walton County. Littrell and his wife, Leighanne, accuse their neighbor, Carolyn Barrington Hill, of consistently entering their private beach area. The incidents reportedly occurred throughout the spring and summer of 2025.

Details of the Alleged Harassment and Trespassing

The lawsuit outlines a series of confrontations. Hill is accused of ignoring clearly posted ‘No Trespassing’ signs. She allegedly set up beach furniture on the Littrells’ property without permission.

Court papers detail specific dates of the alleged incidents. These include April 26, May 4, and several dates in June, August, and September. The family claims Hill repeatedly filmed them without consent, causing significant distress.

On at least one occasion, law enforcement was called. A Walton County Sheriff’s Deputy reportedly ordered Hill to leave the beach area. Despite this, the alleged behavior continued, forcing the Littrells to hire private security.

The Legal and Community Impact of the Dispute

This case touches on a sensitive issue in Florida. The state’s beaches are governed by complex laws regarding public and private access. The wet sand area is typically public, while the dry sand can be privately owned.

Littrell’s attorney, Peter Ticktin, stated his clients purchased the property for peace and privacy. He described the situation as a campaign of harassment. The legal action seeks to enforce their property rights and stop the alleged intrusions.

Carolyn Barrington Hill has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. She argues the claims are legally insufficient. A hearing on this motion is scheduled for December 11, 2025.

Videos of the beach confrontations have surfaced on social media. An Instagram account called ‘Shoreline Defender’ has posted several clips. This has amplified the local dispute into a broader public debate.

The outcome of this case could set a precedent. It may influence how similar neighbor disputes over beach access are handled in the future. Both sides appear prepared for a prolonged legal fight.

The Brian Littrell lawsuit represents more than a neighborly spat. It underscores the challenges of balancing private property rights with traditional beach access in Florida. The resolution of this case will be closely watched by coastal property owners and beachgoers alike.

Thought you’d like to know

What is Brian Littrell suing his neighbor for?

He is suing for alleged trespassing and harassment. The lawsuit claims his neighbor repeatedly entered his private beach area. It also accuses her of filming his family without consent.

Where does Brian Littrell’s beach house lawsuit take place?

The property is located in Santa Rosa Beach, Florida. This is in Walton County on the state’s Gulf Coast. The region is known for its beautiful beaches and high-value real estate.

What are the specific allegations in the Littrell lawsuit?

The suit lists multiple specific dates of alleged trespassing. It claims the neighbor set up furniture and refused to leave when asked. The family also alleges they were filmed without permission on several occasions.

How has the neighbor responded to the lawsuit?

Carolyn Barrington Hill has filed a motion to dismiss the case. She argues the legal claims are insufficient. Her response sets the stage for a December 2025 court hearing.

Why is this lawsuit significant beyond this specific case?

It highlights the ongoing conflict over beach access rights in Florida. The case could influence how similar disputes are resolved. It tests the boundaries between private property and public beach use.

Have there been any police involved in this dispute?

Yes, Walton County Sheriff’s deputies responded to at least one incident. An officer reportedly ordered Hill to leave the beach. The Littrells also sued the sheriff’s office for not preventing trespassing.