California High School Principal Exits in Grindr Student Scandal

A former California high school principal has left his post amid serious misconduct allegations. Jonathan M. Fey, the ex-principal of Amador Valley High School, was accused of using the dating app Grindr to contact students. The Pleasanton Unified School District investigated and confirmed the claims, leading to his termination.

Fey accepted a substantial financial settlement instead of facing a public disciplinary hearing. This resolution has sparked significant public debate over accountability and the use of public funds. The case highlights ongoing concerns about educator conduct and student safety in the digital age.

Investigation Uncovers Inappropriate Communications

According to the district’s findings, an account on Grindr was linked to Fey. This account, identified by an “eyes emoji” username, engaged in conversations of a sexual nature. Investigators reported these discussions involved at least one current and one former student.

One student stated that after an interaction on the app, Fey began following him on Instagram. Another student reported receiving a message from the account calling him “hella hot.” These digital interactions formed the core of the evidence against the administrator. Fey has publicly denied the allegations, suggesting his identity was stolen.

District Reaches Settlement Amid Public Outcry

The school district moved to dismiss Fey following its internal investigation. Rather than contest the termination in a public forum, Fey agreed to a settlement. The agreement totaled $254,000 and was finalized in early 2025.

This payout includes provisions for legal fees and back pay. The decision to settle has drawn criticism from parents and community members. Many question the use of taxpayer money to resolve a personnel matter involving such serious allegations. The situation has eroded trust in the school’s leadership.

The California Commission on Teacher Credentialing is now reviewing the case. This state body has the authority to revoke Fey’s teaching credentials. Such an action would effectively end his career in public education.

The resolution of the Jonathan M. Fey case underscores the critical need for robust ethical standards for school administrators. This Grindr student scandal serves as a stark reminder of the complex challenges facing modern educational institutions.

Info at your fingertips

What was Jonathan M. Fey accused of?

He was accused of using the Grindr dating app to engage in inappropriate conversations. These communications were with at least one current and one former student from Amador Valley High School.

What was the outcome of the investigation?

The Pleasanton Unified School District investigation found sufficient evidence of misconduct. Fey was placed on leave and later terminated from his position as principal.

How much was the settlement for?

Jonathan M. Fey accepted a settlement of $254,000 from the school district. This agreement prevented a public hearing on his termination.

Has Jonathan M. Fey admitted to the allegations?

No, he has publicly denied all accusations. Fey has claimed that someone impersonated him on the dating app.

Could Jonathan M. Fey work as an educator again?

His future in education is uncertain. The California Commission on Teacher Credentialing is reviewing the case and could revoke his credentials.