Why Lea Michele and Aaron Tveits Broadway Chess Revival Earned Mixed Reviews

Chess Broadway Revival Opens to Mixed Reviews Amid Stellar Performances

The highly anticipated Broadway revival of “Chess” officially premiered on November 16, 2025. The production opened at New York’s Imperial Theatre after a month of preview performances. It features a star-studded cast including Lea Michele, Aaron Tveit, and Nicholas Christopher.

This marks the musical’s return to Broadway after a 37-year absence. The show combines a Cold War narrative with the iconic music of ABBA’s Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus.

Chess Broadway Revival

A Divided Critical Response

Early reviews from major publications presented a divided consensus. According to Variety, the production felt uneven despite powerhouse vocal performances. The Hollywood Reporter noted the show seemed emotionally at war with itself.

Lea Michele’s performance as Florence Vassy emerged as the unanimous highlight. Critics praised her technical skill and emotional delivery. Her rendition of “Nobody’s Side” was singled out as a standout moment.

Nicholas Christopher also earned significant praise for his portrayal of the Soviet champion. Aaron Tveit delivered a solid performance as the American grandmaster. The trio’s chemistry provided the show’s most compelling moments.

Production Strengths and Weaknesses

The musical’s legendary score received universal acclaim from audiences and critics. Songs like “Anthem” and “I Know Him So Well” landed with powerful effect. The new orchestral arrangements highlighted the music’s enduring quality.

However, the book continued to present challenges for the production. The complicated plot about geopolitical tensions confused some viewers. Character motivations sometimes felt unclear despite strong acting.

Director Michael Mayer’s staging featured innovative visual elements. David Rockwell’s minimalist set design used staircases to create multiple levels. Kevin Adams’ lighting emphasized the red-and-blue color scheme of Cold War symbolism.

Box Office Prospects and Run

The production has already extended its run through May 3, 2026. Strong advance sales suggest solid financial prospects. Lea Michele’s fan base has contributed significantly to early ticket demand.

The show faces typical Broadway challenges in maintaining momentum. Mixed reviews may impact casual theatergoer attendance. However, the ABBA score and star power provide considerable drawing power.

Industry observers will watch how the show performs through the traditionally slower winter months. The production’s $229 top ticket price represents a significant investment for audiences. Its success may influence future revivals of challenging musicals.

The Chess Broadway revival delivers exceptional performances despite narrative flaws, making it a compelling night at the theater for fans of the score and its leading lady.

Thought you’d like to know

How long is the Chess Broadway runtime?

The show runs approximately 2 hours and 45 minutes. This includes one intermission between acts. The length allows for the full development of the complex story.

What is the ticket price range?

Tickets range from $99 to $229 for premium seats. Prices vary based on performance date and seat location. Discounts may be available for midweek shows.

Who composed the music for Chess?

ABBA members Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus composed the music. Lyricist Tim Rice wrote the words. The collaboration created one of musical theater’s most beloved scores.

How does this revival differ from previous productions?

This production features a completely new book by Danny Strong. The director has reimagined the staging for modern audiences. The focus remains on character relationships amid political tension.

Is the show suitable for children?

The complex themes are best suited for teenagers and adults. Children under 10 may find the political storyline confusing. Parental discretion is advised for younger theatergoers.