Death by Lightning Review: A Riveting But Rushed Historical Drama

Netflix has released a new historical drama about a presidential assassination. “Death by Lightning” premiered on Thursday, November 6. The series stars Michael Shannon and Matthew Macfadyen. It chronicles the political rise and tragic fall of President James Garfield.

The show explores the parallel stories of Garfield and his assassin, Charles Guiteau. It is based on Candice Millard’s acclaimed book “Destiny of the Republic”. This limited series aims to resurrect a forgotten American tragedy for a modern audience.

Garfield and Guiteau’s Parallel Paths

The series begins with James Garfield’s reluctant journey to the Republican National Convention. He is a man of principle, pushed into the political spotlight. Michael Shannon portrays Garfield with intelligence and grouchy decency.

Meanwhile, Matthew Macfadyen’s Charles Guiteau is a delusional figure seeking purpose. His story is one of childhood trauma and grandiosity. The show effectively builds their worlds over three compelling episodes.

A Strong Cast Anchors the Story

The supporting cast delivers exceptional performances. Nick Offerman plays a drunken Chester Arthur with surprising depth. Betty Gilpin brings modern sensibility to her role as Garfield’s wife, Lucretia.

Bradley Whitford and Shea Whigham round out the political players. They represent the corrupt New York political machine opposing Garfield. According to Reuters, the series benefits greatly from this ensemble’s chemistry.

A Hasty Conclusion Diminishes Impact

The series stumbles in its final act. It rushes through Garfield’s prolonged death, which historically lasted over two months. This was a period rich with medical drama and innovation.

The trial and imprisonment of Guiteau also feel abbreviated. Key historical figures like Frederick Douglass are underutilized. This haste leaves the audience wanting a more thorough conclusion.

“Death by Lightning” delivers powerful performances and historical intrigue. Its rushed finale, however, prevents it from achieving true greatness. The series remains a compelling, if flawed, look at a pivotal moment in American history.

Info at your fingertips

What is “Death by Lightning” about?

It is a Netflix historical drama about President James Garfield’s assassination. The series follows both Garfield and his killer, Charles Guiteau. It is based on Candice Millard’s book “Destiny of the Republic”.

Who stars in the series?

Michael Shannon plays President James Garfield. Matthew Macfadyen portrays his assassin, Charles Guiteau. The supporting cast includes Nick Offerman, Betty Gilpin, and Bradley Whitford.

How many episodes are in the series?

The limited series consists of four episodes. It premiered on Netflix on November 6. The entire story is contained within this single season.

Is the series historically accurate?

It generally sticks to known historical facts. Some characters and events are condensed for dramatic purposes. The book it’s based on is well-researched nonfiction.

Why did the series receive mixed reviews?

Critics praised the acting and first three episodes. Many felt the final episode rushed through important historical events. The conclusion left some viewers unsatisfied.