Netflix’s Death by Lightning Earns Staggering 91% Rotten Tomatoes Score

Netflix’s new historical drama “Death by Lightning” has achieved a stellar 91% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The series premiered globally on November 6, 2025. It stars Michael Shannon and Matthew Macfadyen in leading roles. This critically acclaimed show dramatizes the assassination of President James Garfield.

The series has been certified “Fresh” by the review aggregator. This places it among Netflix’s top-rated original programs for the year. According to Rotten Tomatoes, the score is based on dozens of professional critic reviews.

A Deep Dive into a Presidential Tragedy

“Death by Lightning” chronicles the life and tragic death of the 20th U.S. President. James Garfield served only 200 days in office before his assassination. The series explores both his political rise and the events leading to his shooting.

Michael Shannon delivers a powerful performance as President Garfield. Matthew Macfadyen portrays Charles Guiteau, Garfield’s assassin. The cast also includes notable actors like Nick Offerman and Betty Gilpin.

The show’s creators previously worked on the epic series “Game of Thrones.” They bring the same production quality to this historical drama. Every episode features meticulous attention to period details and costumes.

Why Critics Are Raving About This Series

Reviewers consistently praise the show’s writing and acting performances. Many highlight the psychological depth given to both Garfield and his assassin. The series avoids simple hero-villain dynamics.

Historical accuracy remains a key strength throughout the production. The show reveals how medical errors actually caused Garfield’s death. This adds layers of tragedy to an already compelling story.

For modern audiences, the series offers surprising relevance. It explores political division and the instability of leadership. These themes resonate strongly with contemporary viewers.

“Death by Lightning” proves that historical drama can be both educational and utterly gripping, securing its place as must-watch television with its exceptional Rotten Tomatoes score.

Thought you’d like to know

What is “Death by Lightning” about?

The series tells the true story of President James Garfield’s rise to power and assassination. It explores both his political career and the motives of his killer. The title references the medical cause of his death.

How many episodes are in the series?

“Death by Lightning” consists of four episodes. All episodes were released simultaneously on Netflix. This allows viewers to binge-watch the entire story.

Is the series historically accurate?

The show maintains strong historical accuracy regarding major events. Some dramatic license is taken with dialogue and minor character interactions. Overall, it faithfully represents this tragic chapter in American history.

Who are the main actors in the cast?

Michael Shannon plays President James Garfield. Matthew Macfadyen portrays Charles Guiteau, his assassin. The supporting cast includes Nick Offerman as Vice President Chester Arthur.

Why did the series receive such high ratings?

Critics praised the outstanding performances and compelling storytelling. The show’s production quality and historical depth impressed reviewers. Its fresh take on a lesser-known historical event also contributed to positive reviews.