Eddie Murphy Defends ‘Norbit’: Why the Comedian Stands By His Controversial Film

Eddie Murphy’s legendary career features towering comedic achievements alongside a few infamous misfires. While critics have long maligned 2007’s Norbit as a low point, Murphy himself delivers a passionate defense of the film, revealing a surprising personal affection for the project that sparked an Oscar backlash and Razzie ridicule.

Why Does Eddie Murphy Still Defend ‘Norbit’?

Speaking candidly with Complex in 2024, Murphy addressed his filmography’s perceived weak spots. When Norbit came up, he didn’t flinch: “I love Norbit,” Murphy stated emphatically. He directly linked the film’s critical savagery to its unfortunate timing, released shortly after his acclaimed, Oscar-nominated turn in Dreamgirls: “There were articles, it was like, ‘How can he get an Oscar, he did this.’ It’s like two different movies.” Murphy emphasized the film’s personal roots, co-writing it with his brother Charlie Murphy, asserting, “We think Norbit is funny.” This sentiment found an unlikely fan in the late Beach Boys legend Brian Wilson, who notably declared it his favorite movie.

The Norbit backlash had tangible consequences. Murphy lost the 2007 Best Supporting Actor Oscar (won by Alan Arkin for Little Miss Sunshine), with many industry observers blaming Norbit‘s negative reception. The film became a Razzie Awards target, earning Murphy nominations for Worst Actor, Worst Supporting Actor, and Worst Supporting Actress – a unique feat achieved through his multiple roles. Murphy recalled the experience with lingering disbelief: “I was like, ‘come on, man, the shit ain’t that bad.’ They was just hating on me. I like Norbit, to this day, I like Norbit. There’s stuff in Norbit that makes me laugh.” He contrasts this with clear admissions about films he does consider missteps, like The Adventures of Pluto Nash and Holy Man.

Beyond the Backlash: ‘Norbit’s’ Legacy and Murphy’s Craft

Despite its critical mauling, Norbit showcased Murphy’s unparalleled physical comedy and character work. He played three distinct roles: the meek title character, the kind but gruff orphanage owner Mr. Wong, and the outrageously domineering Rasputia, Norbit’s abusive wife. The plot followed Norbit’s tumultuous life and his chance at redemption when his childhood sweetheart returns. While reviews were scathing (holding a dismal 9% on Rotten Tomatoes based on critical consensus as of 2024), the film resonated with audiences. It earned a surprising $159 million globally, proving significant commercial success. For Murphy, the project remains a point of pride in his comedic repertoire, distinct from his acknowledged failures.

Eddie Murphy’s enduring defense of Norbit highlights the complex relationship between critical reception, personal artistic satisfaction, and audience response. While the film remains divisive, Murphy’s unwavering stance, rooted in creative partnership and genuine amusement, challenges its status as his “worst” work. His current projects, like the action-comedy The Pickup on Prime Video, continue his legacy, but his passionate advocacy for Norbit offers a fascinating glimpse into how artists value their own creations versus public perception. Revisit Norbit yourself and decide – does Murphy’s comedic vision hold up?

Must Know

Why was Norbit so controversial when it came out?
Norbit arrived just after Eddie Murphy’s Oscar-nominated performance in Dreamgirls, creating a jarring contrast for critics and awards voters. Many felt its broad, often crass humor and Murphy’s portrayal of Rasputia (seen by some as a negative stereotype) undermined his dramatic credibility. This timing fueled a significant backlash that arguably impacted his Oscar chances.

Did Norbit really hurt Eddie Murphy’s Oscar win for Dreamgirls?
While Alan Arkin won the 2007 Best Supporting Actor Oscar for Little Miss Sunshine, widespread media coverage at the time (including reports from outlets like Variety and The Hollywood Reporter) suggested Norbit‘s negative reception was a major factor in Murphy’s loss. The film became a focal point for those questioning the seriousness of his career.

What roles did Eddie Murphy play in Norbit?
Murphy performed three main roles: Norbit Rice, the timid protagonist; Mr. Wong, the elderly Chinese man who runs the orphanage where Norbit grows up; and Rasputia Latimore, Norbit’s loud, abusive, and domineering wife. The extensive makeup and prosthetics were a hallmark of the film.

Was Norbit a box office flop?
Surprisingly, no. Despite terrible reviews, Norbit was a commercial success. It opened at number one at the US box office and ultimately grossed over $159 million worldwide against a reported $60 million budget, according to Box Office Mojo data.

What movies does Eddie Murphy actually consider bad?
In the same Complex interview, Murphy explicitly named The Adventures of Pluto Nash (2002) and Holy Man (1998) as films he considers low points in his career, showing he does critically assess his own work but draws a clear line excluding Norbit.