Ella McCay Review: James L. Brooks’ Political Comedy Misses the Mark

The new film “Ella McCay” arrives in theaters this December. Directed by Oscar-winner James L. Brooks, it stars Emma Mackey as a young governor. The comedy has been met with disappointment from early reviews.It marks Brooks’s first directorial effort in 15 years. The film features a strong supporting cast including Jamie Lee Curtis and Woody Harrelson. Despite the talent, critics say the project feels surprisingly dated.

A Dated Script and Mismatched Tone

Emma Mackey plays Ella McCay, a policy wonk turned governor. The story is set in 2008, which Brooks calls a “better time.” This setting allows the film to avoid modern politics and social media.Critics note the script feels like a relic from a past era. The humor often pitches too high, lacking the emotional core of Brooks’s classics. Mackey’s performance is commended, but her character seems implausibly young for the role.The plot juggles too many cumbersome subplots. Ella deals with a deadbeat father, a problematic husband, and an agoraphobic brother. These elements create a contrived and discursive narrative that fails to gel.

A Stellar Cast Cannot Save the Film’s Direction

Jamie Lee Curtis and Woody Harrelson give energetic performances. Their work indulges the film’s broad, screwball comedy instincts. Some reviews suggest they may be trying too hard for the legendary director.Albert Brooks provides a welcome, dry presence in a small role. The film also features Ayo Edebiri in a seemingly needless subplot. The overall package feels like a copy of a classic Brooks film, lacking its original spark.In the years since Brooks’s last film, comedy has evolved significantly. His traditional style now feels out of step with modern audiences. The film’s score and narration further contribute to an outdated feeling.

Unknown Thriller “A Mother’s Confession” Tops Tubi Charts, Beating Major Films

The final result is a political fairy tale that disappoints. “Ella McCay” struggles to connect with contemporary viewers. This James L. Brooks project ultimately feels like a missed opportunity.

Thought you’d like to know

What is ‘Ella McCay’ about?

The film follows a young policy expert who becomes governor. She navigates the new role while dealing with complex family dynamics. It is a political comedy set in 2008.

Who stars in the new James L. Brooks movie?

Emma Mackey plays the lead role of Governor Ella McCay. Jamie Lee Curtis and Woody Harrelson play key supporting family roles. Albert Brooks and Ayo Edebiri also appear in the cast.

When is the ‘Ella McCay’ release date?

The film is scheduled for release on December 12, 2025. It will open in theaters nationwide. The studio behind the release is 20th Century Studios.

How does it compare to Brooks’ earlier films?

Critics say it lacks the emotional depth of his classics like “Terms of Endearment.” The humor and storytelling feel notably dated. It is considered a step below his acclaimed works from the 80s and 90s.

Why is the film set in 2008?

Director James L. Brooks stated he wanted to depict a “better time.” The setting avoids contemporary political controversies. It also sidesteps the complicated role of modern social media.