Hallmark’s “Finding Mr. Christmas” is returning for a second season. The search for the next holiday heartthrob begins on October 27. Host Jonathan Bennett recently gave fans a unique first look.
He shared the new batch of contestants with some of Hallmark’s leading ladies. Their unfiltered, blushing reactions have created major buzz ahead of the premiere.

Sarah Drew Was Blushing & Nikki DeLoach Was Speechless
Jonathan Bennett shared a hilarious video on his Instagram. It featured actresses like Sarah Drew and Nikki DeLoach reviewing the contestants. Their genuine excitement was immediately clear.
Sarah Drew giggled and pulled away from Bennett. She exclaimed there were “too many muscles” for her to handle. The clip quickly showcased the charming men vying for the title.
A contestant named Davey received significant praise. Erin Cahill reminded herself she was “a happily married woman.” Another, named Marcus, left Nikki DeLoach momentarily speechless.
Rachel Boston said Marcus’s look was “inspired.” The ladies also appreciated a contestant named Robbie. Boston noted she was “feeling joy” when she saw him.
The positive reactions continued throughout the video. The contestants’ diverse talents and appearances clearly made a strong impression. This sneak peek has successfully heightened anticipation for the season.
Hallmark Fans and Colleagues Adored the Fun Video
The comment section on Bennett’s post flooded with positive feedback. Fellow Hallmark stars and fans alike shared their enthusiasm. The video proved to be a highly effective promotional tool.
Contestant Robbie Simpson commented, “Ohhh I’m blushing.” Bennett’s husband, Jaymes Vaughan, humorously compared his reaction to the actresses. The engagement showed the close-knit Hallmark community.
Sharon Lawrence commented that the ladies’ reactions were her exact thoughts. Fans echoed this sentiment in their own comments. One viewer declared the video was “the perfect promo.”
Another fan summed up the general feeling with a simple rave. They called the lineup “Holy holiday hotness!” The collective response suggests a very successful season is ahead.
The new season promises delightful entertainment and charming contestants. Fans are eagerly counting down to the October 27 premiere. Finding Mr. Christmas season 2 is set to be a festive highlight.
Thought you’d like to know-
When does Finding Mr. Christmas season 2 start?
The premiere date is set for October 27. New episodes will air on the Hallmark Channel. The show is part of the network’s annual Countdown to Christmas event.
Who is hosting Finding Mr. Christmas?
Jonathan Bennett returns as the host for the second season. He is a popular Hallmark star and a fan favorite. Bennett also hosts other competition shows for the network.
What is the format of the show?
Contestants compete in various holiday-themed challenges. The goal is to be crowned the ultimate “Mr. Christmas.” It is a reality dating competition with a festive twist.
Which Hallmark stars reacted to the contestants?
Sarah Drew, Nikki DeLoach, Erin Cahill, and Rachel Boston shared their thoughts. Their hilarious and genuine reactions were captured in a video. The clip was shared on Jonathan Bennett’s Instagram.
Where can I watch the show?
Finding Mr. Christmas airs on the Hallmark Channel. Viewers can also stream episodes on the network’s Peacock channel. Check local listings for exact times.
Get the latest News first — Follow us on Google News, Twitter, Facebook, Telegram , subscribe to our YouTube channel and Read Breaking News. For any inquiries, contact: [email protected]



