NFL Draft Analyst Todd McShay Backs LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier as Top 2026 QB Prospect

LSU quarterback Garrett Nussmeier remains the top quarterback prospect for the 2026 NFL Draft. This is according to veteran analyst Todd McShay. McShay made the declaration this week despite Nussmeier’s challenging season.

The Tigers’ starter has battled injuries and inconsistent play through seven games. His performance has not matched the high expectations set after his strong 2023 campaign. This has impacted LSU’s overall record and playoff aspirations.

McShay Points to External Factors in Nussmeier’s Season

McShay explained his reasoning on ‘The Triple Option’ show. He believes current struggles do not reflect Nussmeier’s true talent. The analyst specifically cited the Ole Miss game as an outlier.

He praised Nussmeier for fighting through injuries. McShay also pointed to significant challenges around the quarterback. He stated that LSU’s protection has been a problem this year. The receiving corps also lacks its typical elite talent.

Long-Term NFL Outlook Remains Positive

McShay sees a promising professional future for the LSU signal-caller. He compared Nussmeier’s playing style to that of NFL quarterback Baker Mayfield. The analyst values Nussmeier’s football IQ and ability to play in rhythm.

He acknowledges the quarterback must overcome certain physical limitations. Nussmeier is not the biggest, fastest, or strongest arm in the class. Yet, his understanding of the game gives him a clear pathway to NFL success.

Garrett Nussmeier’s draft stock appears resilient despite on-field hurdles. Expert analysis suggests his foundational skills keep him at the forefront of the 2026 NFL Draft quarterback conversation.

Thought you’d like to know-

Why is Garrett Nussmeier still a top QB prospect?

Analysts like Todd McShay focus on his proven skills and football intelligence. They believe current struggles are due to injury and team issues, not a lack of talent.

How has Nussmeier performed against ranked teams?

His stats are lower against top competition. He has 654 total passing yards and a 1-2 record in three games against ranked opponents this season.

What is the biggest challenge for Nussmeier at LSU?

McShay identified two main problems: inconsistent pass protection and a receiving group that isn’t as strong as in previous LSU seasons.

Who did McShay compare Nussmeier to?

He compared his playing style to NFL quarterback Baker Mayfield. He noted a similar approach to the game, though not an identical arm talent.

What is Nussmeier’s connection to the NFL?

His father, Doug Nussmeier, is the offensive coordinator for the New Orleans Saints. This provides him with a deep background in professional offensive systems.