Golden Bachelor Finale Stuns With Promise Ring Twist

The Golden Bachelor season 2 concluded on November 13, 2025. Retired NFL linebacker Mel Owens, 66, chose Peg Munson, 62. He presented her with a commitment ring instead of a traditional engagement ring.

The move sparked immediate controversy among viewers. Many fans questioned the show’s outcome. They felt a promise ring contradicted the show’s premise of finding a life partner.

Final Rose Ceremony Ends Without Proposal

Mel Owens stood with his final two women, Peg Munson and Cindy Cullers. Cindy made the decision to leave before the final ceremony. She expressed doubts about Mel’s readiness for marriage.

Mel then presented Peg with a stunning Neil Lane ring. He explicitly stated it was a symbol of their commitment to love. He said it was not a marriage proposal, according to People Magazine.

The moment created a wave of fan reactions online. Critics argued it defeated the purpose of the dating show. Supporters said it reflected a more realistic approach for their age group.

Viewer Backlash and Ring Symbolism

Social media erupted with criticism following the finale. Many viewers expressed disappointment for Peg. They felt she deserved a clear proposal after the emotional journey.

Neil Lane designed the custom piece featuring over 30 diamonds. The 3.5-carat ring included a central cushion-cut stone. Two triangle-shaped diamonds represented Mel and Peg’s individual lives.

Lane explained his design philosophy to People Magazine. He aimed to honor their past experiences while symbolizing a new union. The Art Deco style reflected a classic, timeless commitment.

The Golden Bachelor finale’s unconventional ending demonstrates evolving attitudes toward commitment in later life. This promise ring twist will likely fuel discussions about reality television authenticity for weeks to come.

Thought you’d like to know-

Did Mel and Peg get engaged?

They entered a committed relationship, but Mel did not propose marriage. He offered a promise ring to symbolize their continuing connection without setting a wedding date.

Why did Cindy Cullers leave the show?

Cindy self-eliminated before the final ceremony. She felt Mel wasn’t emotionally prepared for the immediate marriage the show typically promises.

What were the details of the promise ring?

Neil Lane created a custom 3.5-carat ring with over 30 diamonds. The design featured a cushion-cut center stone flanked by two triangle diamonds on an 18K gold band.

How have fans reacted to the finale?

Reactions are deeply divided across social media platforms. Many viewers expressed disappointment, while others appreciated the honest approach to senior dating.

Are Mel and Peg still together?

Sources confirm they remain in a relationship post-filming. They are taking things slowly without rushing toward marriage plans.

Will there be a Golden Bachelor season 3?

ABC has not made an official announcement about the franchise’s future. The network typically evaluates viewer response before renewing dating shows.