Hallmark’s Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 Promises More Hunks and Heart

Hallmark Channel’s hit reality competition “Finding Mr. Christmas” is returning for a second season. The show premieres on October 27, 2025. Host Jonathan Bennett promises an even bigger and better season.

The search is on for the next great Hallmark leading man. The winner will secure a role in an upcoming 2025 Hallmark Christmas movie. According to EntertainmentNow, the new season has dialed up every element that made the first a success.

Jonathan Bennett’s Three Big Promises for Season Two

Jonathan Bennett, the show’s co-creator and host, made three specific pledges. He told EntertainmentNow to expect “a lot more hunkiness” this season. The casting process found exceptionally charming and handsome contestants.

The show judges men on acting ability and their overall persona. Bennett stated that a Hallmark leading man needs five key traits. These are charm, humor, kindness, acting skill, and being attractive.

This season’s contestants include a former NFL player and a fitness model. One contestant is a personal trainer and father. Bennett described one man as looking like a “Disney prince.”

Heartfelt Moments and Wild Challenges Await

Beyond the looks, Bennett promised plenty of “melt your heart” moments. The show fosters a unique environment of vulnerability and friendship. The competitors often leave the experience as close friends.

Bennett shared that the season two cast has already formed strong bonds. They continue to spend time together off-camera. This genuine connection creates authentic television.

The challenges have also been intensified for the new season. They are described as crazier and more physically demanding. The acting tests now more closely mimic real on-set pressures, like working with animals.

The hunt for the next holiday heartthrob begins soon. “Finding Mr. Christmas” season two promises to deliver the perfect blend of charm and competition. Fans will not want to miss this festive face-off.

Thought you’d like to know

When does Finding Mr. Christmas season 2 start?

The new season premieres on October 27, 2025. It will air on the Hallmark Channel at 8 p.m. Eastern Time. Episodes will be available on Hallmark+ the following day.

Who are the contestants on Finding Mr. Christmas?

The cast includes a diverse group of men from various backgrounds. Contestants include a former NFL player, a model, and a personal trainer. The show features what host Jonathan Bennett calls “serious hunks.”

What is the prize for winning the show?

The winner receives a role in a 2025 Hallmark Christmas movie. This is a major career launch within the popular holiday film genre. It is the ultimate prize for any aspiring Hallmark star.

How is the show different from other competitions?

It emphasizes kindness and heart alongside talent and appearance. Contestants often form deep, genuine friendships during filming. The environment is supportive despite the competitive nature.

Why was the show created?

It was created to discover new leading men for Hallmark’s movie universe. The network seeks actors who embody its specific values of charm and wholesomeness. It is a direct pipeline for fresh talent.