HBO Max’s “Heated Rivalry” Criticized by Actor Over Unrealistic Gay Sex Scenes

HBO Max‘s hit drama “Heated Rivalry” is facing criticism. Actor Jordan Firstman of “I Love LA” says the show fails to portray authentic gay intimacy. He made the comments in a recent interview with Vulture.

Heated Rivalry (L to R) – Connor Storrie as Ilya Rozanov and Hudson Williams as Shane Hollander in Episode 104 of Heated Rivalry. Cr. Sabrina Lantos © 2025

The show follows two professional hockey players in a secret romance. Its steamy scenes have been a major talking point. Firstman argues a scene in his own series better captures real gay sexual dynamics.

Firstman Claims “Heated Rivalry” Lacks Authentic Gay Experience

Jordan Firstman did not hold back in his critique. He stated the intimate moments in “Heated Rivalry” are simply not how gay people have sex. He pointed to a specific moment in “I Love LA” as a more truthful depiction.

In that scene, his character watches a personal sex tape. Both participants say “that part” afterwards. Firstman says this small, shared joke is rooted in real gay camaraderie. He believes a straight writer could not authentically capture that specific feeling.

The actor emphasized the rarity of genuine gay sex scenes on screen. He feels most depictions are sanitized or inaccurate. This, he argues, makes authentic portrayals like his own crucial for representation.

Both Criticized and Critic Show Secure Season 2 Renewals

Despite the criticism, “Heated Rivalry” is a certified success. HBO Max quickly renewed it for a second season. The next chapter will adapt “The Long Game,” the sixth book in the “Game Changers” series.

Stars Hudson Williams and Connor Storrie announced the renewal. Creator Jacob Tierney spoke to Entertainment Weekly about the show’s future. He hopes for more resources but wants to keep the show’s spirit intact.

Meanwhile, Jordan Firstman’s “I Love LA” is also returning. HBO renewed the comedy series last November. This ensures both sides of this creative debate will continue their stories.

The debate ignited by Jordan Firstman highlights a growing demand for authentic LGBTQ+ narratives. As “Heated Rivalry” prepares for its next season, the conversation about realistic representation in streaming content is more heated than ever.

Info at your fingertips

What did Jordan Firstman say about “Heated Rivalry”?

Jordan Firstman criticized the HBO Max show for its portrayal of gay sex. He stated its scenes are not authentic to real gay intimacy. He contrasted it with a more truthful moment in his own series, “I Love LA.”

Has “Heated Rivalry” been renewed for Season 2?

Yes, “Heated Rivalry” has been renewed for a second season. The announcement was made by HBO Max. The new season will adapt the next novel in the book series, “The Long Game.”

What show does Jordan Firstman star in?

Jordan Firstman stars in the HBO comedy series “I Love LA.” His comments criticizing “Heated Rivalry” came from an interview about this show. “I Love LA” has also been renewed for a second season.

What was the creator’s response to the show’s success?

Creator Jacob Tierney expressed immense happiness with the show’s reception. He told Entertainment Weekly he would welcome more resources for Season 2. However, he aims to maintain the show’s original spirit and direction.

Where were Jordan Firstman’s comments published?

His critique was published in an interview with Vulture. The outlet covers entertainment and pop culture news. The interview focused on the differences in portraying intimacy on television.