Heisman Hype to Playoff Reality: The Quarterback Slump Defining the CFP Matchup

The Oklahoma Sooners face the Alabama Crimson Tide in the College Football Playoff. Their quarterbacks entered the season as Heisman Trophy favorites. Both players saw their campaigns fade dramatically in the second half. The game in Norman on December 19th will be decided by which signal-caller can break their slump.

According to ESPN, the statistical decline for both John Mateer and Ty Simpson is stark. Their parallel drop in production adds a compelling layer to this high-stakes playoff rematch. The team that gets better quarterback play will likely advance.

John Mateer’s Season Derailed by Injury and Inconsistency

Oklahoma’s John Mateer started the year on fire. He led the Sooners to a 4-0 record with wins over Auburn and Michigan. He tallied over 1,200 passing yards and 11 touchdowns in that dominant stretch.

A right-hand injury against Auburn changed everything. Mateer needed surgery and missed a game. His performance after returning was never the same. He completed under 59% of his passes with more interceptions than touchdowns in the final seven games.

Coach Brent Venables has defended his quarterback. He points to other factors beyond pure statistics. Venables stresses that winning is the ultimate measure, not just passing numbers.

Ty Simpson’s Mirror-Image Struggle for Alabama

Alabama’s Ty Simpson followed an identical path. His first eight games were brilliant, with 21 touchdowns to just one interception. His efficiency made him the Heisman frontrunner for much of October.

His final games told a different story. Simpson’s completion percentage and touchdown rate plummeted. He threw four interceptions in the last four games, including a tough outing in the SEC title game loss to Georgia.

In the first matchup against Oklahoma, Simpson showed both sides. He passed for 326 yards but also turned the ball over twice. The Sooner defense rattled him, a key factor in their narrow victory.

Info at your fingertips

When is the Oklahoma vs. Alabama playoff game?

The College Football Playoff first-round game is scheduled for Friday, December 19th. It will be played at Oklahoma’s home stadium in Norman.

Why did John Mateer’s stats drop so much?

Mateer suffered a significant right-hand injury in September. He underwent surgery and missed time. His accuracy and production noticeably declined after his return to the field.

How did Ty Simpson play against Oklahoma earlier?

Simpson had 326 passing yards and a touchdown in the first meeting. He also threw an interception and lost a fumble, as Oklahoma’s defense pressured him consistently throughout the game.

Who is favored to win the playoff game?

Early betting lines are very close, indicating a toss-up. Playing at home gives Oklahoma a slight edge, but Alabama’s overall talent keeps them firmly in the contest.

What is the biggest key to the game?

Quarterback performance is the clear deciding factor. Which passer, John Mateer or Ty Simpson, can overcome their recent struggles and deliver under playoff pressure will likely determine the winner.