Horror Fans Outraged as Rolling Stone Snubs Ryan Coogler’s ‘Sinners’

Rolling Stone magazine has omitted a major hit from its best films of 2025 list. The magazine’s editors left out Ryan Coogler’s acclaimed vampire film, “Sinners.” This decision has sparked immediate backlash from horror fans and movie lovers online.The list was published in early December. It featured 20 films, including other horror titles, but not the Warner Bros. blockbuster. The snub is notable given the film’s near-perfect critical and audience scores.

Fan Fury Erupts on Social Media Over List Omission

Reaction on social media platform X was swift and critical. Many users questioned the list’s credibility. Fans pointed to the film’s exceptional ratings as proof of its quality.According to data from Rotten Tomatoes, “Sinners” holds a 97% critics score. Its audience score is an equally impressive 96%. These numbers highlight its broad appeal.The list’s compiler, editor David Fear, faced direct scrutiny. One prominent reply came from Marvel star Mark Ruffalo. He simply asked “Why?” in response to the omission. This amplified the conversation significantly.

A Surprise Omission for a Defining Genre Hit

The omission is seen as a surprise industry snub. “Sinners” was hailed as a fresh take on vampire lore. Its success revived interest in original horror projects this year.Rolling Stone’s list did include other 2025 horror films. Zach Cregger’s “Weapons” was ranked at number 20. This makes the exclusion of “Sinners” more puzzling to commentators.The list was topped by Paul Thomas Anderson’s drama. Other picks included major streaming releases and auteur projects. The absence of Coogler’s hit suggests a notable divergence between critical lists and popular consensus.

Giants Rookie QB Jaxson Dart Faces Intense Scrutiny Over Aggressive Playing Style

The controversy underscores the film’s lasting cultural impact. The debate over Ryan Coogler’s “Sinners” confirms its status as a audience favorite. It remains one of the year’s most talked-about cinematic achievements.

Thought you’d like to know

What is the movie “Sinners” about?

“Sinners” is a vampire film directed by Ryan Coogler. It presents a unique and modern take on vampire mythology. The story is set in a contemporary urban environment.

Why are fans upset with Rolling Stone?

Fans are upset because “Sinners” was left off the best-of list despite high scores. The film has outstanding ratings from both critics and general audiences. Its omission feels like a disregard for popular and critical acclaim.

What were the critical scores for “Sinners”?

On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a 97% approval from critics. The audience score is also very high at 96%. These numbers indicate nearly universal praise.

Did any horror movies make the Rolling Stone list?

Yes, one horror film did make the list. Zach Cregger’s “Weapons” was included at number 20. This makes the exclusion of “Sinners” a point of comparison for fans.

Who directed the film “Sinners”?

The film was directed by Ryan Coogler. He is known for previous major studio hits. This project marked his successful entry into the horror genre.