Hulu’s ‘Are You My First?’ Dating Show Premieres Tonight with 21 Virgin Singles

The reality TV landscape shifts dramatically today as Hulu launches its boldest dating experiment yet. “Are You My First?” premieres August 18, featuring 21 singles who’ve never had sex – the largest gathering of virgins in dating show history. Hosted by Colton Underwood (“Coming Out Colton”) and Kaitlyn Bristowe (“The Bachelorette”), this boundary-pushing series from “Love Island USA” producers promises raw conversations about intimacy, faith, and connection without societal pressure.

Why is “Are You My First?” Revolutionizing Dating Television?

Unlike conventional dating shows focused on physical chemistry, “Are You My First?” creates a judgment-free sanctuary for contestants whose virginity stems from diverse backgrounds. As Hulu describes in their official announcement (August 2025), this “groundbreaking dating experiment” intentionally removes sexual pressure, allowing authentic emotional bonds to form first. Clinical psychologist Dr. Sarah Schewitz notes, “This format could normalize diverse intimacy timelines, challenging the stereotype that physicality must precede emotional connection in relationships” (Psychology Today, 2024). The show’s structure includes:

• Celibacy by Choice: Several contestants like Jake (32, caregiver) and Ty (25, web developer) cite religious convictions
• Personal Journeys: Rachael (30, cocktail waitress) postponed intimacy due to health challenges
• Emotional Barriers: Madi (28, marketing manager) and Michael (26, comedian) openly discuss intimacy fears
  This vulnerability-first approach has already sparked social media debates about modern dating norms.

Meet the Pioneering Cast of 21 Virgin Singles

From NFL cheerleaders to tech entrepreneurs, the cast represents America’s diversity in both background and reasons for preserving their virginity. Jade (28), Miss New Orleans USA, has never had a serious relationship despite her public profile. Vivek (23), an Indian-American financial accountant, prioritizes “trust and true connection” above societal expectations. The most recognizable face is Mike Planeta (34), returning to reality TV after his viral “Bachelorette” 2021 confession about virginity. As he told E! Online (August 2025), “I’m done being the punchline. This is about finding my life partner.” Other standout contestants include:

• Farha (25, Miami content creator): “Waiting for true love” after religious upbringing
• Godwin (27, real estate developer): “Holding out for my queen”
• Krash (24, social media manager): Strict upbringing taught him patience
• Layne (24, commercial pilot): Seeking first serious girlfriend

How Host Experience Shapes the Journey

Underwood and Bristowe bring unique qualifications: Underwood publicly navigated virginity discussions on “The Bachelor,” while Bristowe’s podcast “Off the Vine” frequently explores modern relationships. Their dual perspective helps mediate sensitive conversations about boundaries. Production insiders reveal contestants undergo psychological screenings and intimacy coaching, establishing ethical safeguards rare in reality TV (Variety, July 2025).

The entire 10-episode season streams today on Hulu and Disney+ internationally – a strategic drop allowing binge-watching of this cultural conversation starter.

Must Know

Q: When can I watch “Are You My First?”
A: All 10 episodes launched August 18, 2025 on Hulu in the U.S. and Disney+ globally. The full-season release enables viewers to follow the entire journey without weekly waits.

Q: Who are the hosts and why were they chosen?
A: Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe host. Underwood’s experience with public virginity scrutiny (“The Bachelor”) and Bristowe’s relationship expertise (“The Bachelorette”) provide unique guidance for contestants navigating emotional vulnerability.

Q: What makes this different from other dating shows?
A: It removes physical pressure entirely by exclusively featuring virgins – a first for mainstream reality TV. The focus shifts to emotional intimacy and diverse personal journeys, from religious celibacy to overcoming intimacy fears.

Q: Are there any famous contestants?
A: Yes. Mike Planeta (34), a “Bachelorette” 2021 alumnus, joins the cast. His previous openness about virginity on national TV brings unique perspective to the experiment.

Q: How does the show protect participants’ mental health?
A: Multiple sources confirm psychological screenings, on-set therapists, and aftercare protocols – industry advancements following criticism of older dating shows (The Hollywood Reporter, 2024).

Don’t miss television’s most audacious relationship experiment reshaping how we view intimacy. “Are You My First?” challenges reality TV conventions by celebrating emotional connection over physical expectation – stream the groundbreaking premiere now on Hulu.