ICE Detention of Bronx Teen with Special Status Sparks Legal Battle

A 16-year-old Bronx student was detained by immigration authorities during a routine check-in. Joel Camas, who holds Special Immigrant Juvenile Status, was taken into custody alongside New York City Comptroller Brad Lander. The incident occurred last week and has prompted immediate legal action.

This detention has triggered significant backlash from advocates and officials. According to Reuters, the case highlights ongoing tensions in U.S. immigration enforcement.

Contradictory Narratives Emerge from DHS and Advocates

City Comptroller Brad Lander described the event on social media. He stated that Joel is a model student who loves soccer and pepperoni pizza. Lander expressed shock that the teen was detained despite his protected status.

In response, the Department of Homeland Security presented a different account. DHS officials confirmed that a federal judge issued a final removal order for Camas and his mother in February 2024. They noted his mother subsequently returned to Ecuador.

Legal Fight Intensifies Over Juvenile Immigrant Rights

The New York Civil Liberties Union has filed a habeas petition seeking Joel’s immediate release. His lawyer, Beth Baltimore, emphasized the terrifying uncertainty facing young immigrants. She is fighting to keep Joel in school while he pursues lawful permanent residence.

Joel’s mother, Elvia Chafla, voiced fear for her son’s safety if returned to Ecuador. She cited extreme violence in their home country as the primary reason for their original asylum claim. The family’s case continues to draw national attention to immigration policies.

The legal and humanitarian implications of this ICE detention will likely influence future cases involving vulnerable youth with special status.

Info at your fingertips

What is Special Immigrant Juvenile Status?

It is a legal classification for undocumented minors who have been abused, abandoned, or neglected. This status allows them to apply for lawful permanent residence in the United States. It is designed to protect vulnerable youth.

Why was Joel Camas detained by ICE?

He was detained despite his protected status because of an existing removal order. An immigration judge had previously issued a final order of removal for him and his mother. ICE officials acted on that standing order.

What is the current status of Joel’s case?

His legal team has filed a habeas petition for his release. The New York Civil Liberties Union is involved in the litigation. The goal is to halt his removal and allow him to remain in school.

How has the public reacted to this incident?

There has been significant public outcry from immigrant advocacy groups. Many see the detention as a breach of trust for those complying with check-in requirements. The case has garnered widespread media coverage.

What was the basis for the family’s asylum claim?

Joel and his mother originally sought asylum due to gang violence in Ecuador. Their initial asylum application was not successful. This led to the removal order from the immigration judge.