American Idol Music Supervisor Murder Case Stalled as Judge Rules Defendant Incompetent for Trial

A judge declared the man accused of murdering an American Idol music supervisor and her husband incompetent to stand trial. The ruling was made during a hearing in a Los Angeles courtroom on Thursday. However, the judge later revoked her decision after the defendant refused to appear.

Raymond Boodarian, 22, is charged with the July killings of Robin Kaye and Thomas Deluca. The case is now delayed until a follow-up hearing scheduled for December 19.

Courtroom Drama and a Reversed Ruling

Judge Maria Cavalluzzi initially found Boodarian “not presently competent.” This decision was based on a mental health report from Dr. Phani Tumu. Both the defense and prosecution agreed with the assessment.

The judge also authorized involuntary treatment with psychotropic medication. She stated this was medically appropriate and necessary for restoration. Without it, she said Boodarian would likely suffer serious harm.

Shortly after the ruling, the judge recalled her order. According to a court source who spoke with Rolling Stone, this was because Boodarian was not present. He had refused transportation to the courthouse. The new hearing will revisit the competency issue.

A Tragic Crime and a Complex Legal Path

The victims were found dead in their Encino home on July 14. Officials say they were shot during a daytime burglary. Police allege Boodarian used a gun found inside the house.

According to Reuters reporting on the case, a neighbor reported a break-in attempt on the day of the shooting. Later, Boodarian himself called 911, reportedly saying, “Please don’t shoot me.” Surveillance video placed a suspect matching his description at the scene.

Boodarian has displayed severe mental health issues since his arrest. At an August hearing, he appeared in a suicide gown and did not respond to the judge. His restoration to competency is a necessary step before any murder trial can proceed.

The path to justice for the families of Robin Kaye and Thomas Deluca has hit a significant hurdle. The court’s focus is now on whether the defendant can be restored to competency to face the homicide charges against him.

Info at your fingertips

Who were Robin Kaye and Thomas Deluca?

Robin Kaye was a longtime music supervisor for American Idol. Thomas Deluca was a musician and songwriter who worked with artists like Micky Dolenz of The Monkees.

What does “incompetent to stand trial” mean?

It means a judge has determined a defendant cannot understand the legal proceedings or assist in their own defense. This is often due to a severe mental health condition.

What happens next in this case?

A follow-up hearing is set for December 19. The court will then re-evaluate the defendant’s competency, which will determine if the case can move toward a trial.

What are the charges against Raymond Boodarian?

He is charged with two counts of murder. If convicted, he could face life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Why was the initial ruling revoked?

The judge vacated her own order because the defendant was not present in the courtroom. She wants him physically present at the next hearing.