June Squibb’s New Film “Eleanor the Great” Stirs Debate with Controversial Plot Twist

June Squibb stars in the new drama “Eleanor the Great.” The film marks Scarlett Johansson’s directorial debut. It explores themes of friendship and grief in later life.

However, a central plot device involving a fabricated Holocaust survivor story has sparked significant discussion. The movie releases nationwide this Friday.

Film’s Strong Start Overshadowed by Narrative Choice

According to early reviews, the film begins with a heartfelt portrayal of friendship. Squibb’s character, Eleanor, lives happily in Florida with her best friend Bessie. Their daily routines are depicted with warmth and authenticity.

This idyllic life ends when Bessie dies unexpectedly. Eleanor is forced to relocate to New York City to live with her daughter. She struggles with loneliness and feels like an inconvenience to her family.

Seeking connection, Eleanor visits a local Jewish Community Center. She is mistakenly welcomed into a support group for Holocaust survivors. Instead of correcting the error, she impulsively pretends to be a survivor, sharing her late friend’s story as her own.

Performance Praised Amidst Script Criticism

Critics universally praise June Squibb’s performance. Her portrayal of a woman navigating profound loss is described as moving and genuine. Her chemistry with co-star Naomi Ackie, who plays a journalism student, is a highlight.

Yet, the narrative’s reliance on the false Holocaust survivor premise is widely cited as a flaw. The storyline escalates as the lie grows, leading to a public revelation. This creates a tense and uncomfortable viewing experience for many.

The film attempts to address themes of memory and storytelling. However, analysts suggest this justification feels insufficient for the chosen plot. The focus shifts from a character study to the mechanics of a problematic deception.

“Eleanor the Great” delivers a powerful performance from its lead but is ultimately hampered by a controversial and difficult-to-stomach central plot device. The film’s exploration of grief is compelling, yet its execution remains divisive.

Thought you’d like to know

What is “Eleanor the Great” about?

The film follows a 94-year-old woman who moves to New York after her best friend’s death. Struggling with loneliness, she finds connection by falsely claiming to be a Holocaust survivor. This lie forms the core of the movie’s conflict.

Who stars in the movie?

Oscar-nominated actress June Squibb plays the lead role of Eleanor. The film also features Naomi Ackie as a journalism student who befriends her. It is the first feature film directed by Scarlett Johansson.

Why is the film receiving mixed reviews?

Reviewers praise June Squibb’s performance as heartfelt and authentic. However, the plot’s use of a Holocaust survivor lie is seen by many as a major misstep. This controversial choice overshadows the film’s stronger elements for some critics.

What is the movie’s rating?

The Motion Picture Association has rated “Eleanor the Great” PG-13. This rating is for some language, thematic elements, and suggestive references. The film’s running time is 98 minutes.

Where can I see the film?

“Eleanor the Great” is distributed by Sony Pictures Classics. It will be released in theaters across the country. Check local listings for specific showtimes.