Wayward Season 2: Netflix Yet to Greenlight Return as Cast Holds Out Hope

Netflix has not yet renewed the psychological drama Wayward for a second season. The series, created by and starring Mae Martin, premiered its first season on September 25. Fans are eagerly awaiting news about the fate of the characters from Tall Pines Academy.

Netflix originally marketed the show as a limited series. This classification often indicates a single, self-contained story.

Cast and Creator Open to Continuing the Story

Despite the “limited series” label, the show’s creator is not closing the door. Mae Martin told TV Insider that while it was conceived as a miniseries, more story remains. They specifically noted that all characters were left in a state of crisis.

Martin suggested a second season would explore supporting characters. Figures like Stacey and Mule could see expanded roles. The fallout from Evelyn’s condition and Abbie’s escape would also be central.

Co-star Sarah Gadon agreed the ending was intentionally open. She confirmed that nothing was “tied up in a neat little bow.” This ambiguity provides a natural pathway for new episodes.

Real-World Hurdles for a Potential Renewal

Martin also expressed a practical concern about continuing the narrative. In an interview with Variety, they questioned the realism of the situation continuing without major external intervention. The high body count at Tall Pines would likely attract significant FBI attention quickly.

The cast, however, seems united in their desire to return. Toni Collette called the story “endlessly intriguing.” Alyvia Alyn Lind and Sydney Topliffe also confirmed they would reprise their roles if asked.

A renewal would likely see the return of most main cast members. The exception would be Brandon Jay McLaren, whose character died in the first season. Toni Collette’s return would depend on her character Evelyn’s fate.

The future of Wayward Season 2 now rests with Netflix. The streamer will analyze viewership data before making a final decision. For now, the series remains a compelling one-season mystery.

Thought you’d like to know

Has Wayward been officially renewed?

No, Netflix has not officially renewed Wayward for a second season. The show was initially promoted as a limited series, which suggests a single-season story.

What did Mae Martin say about a second season?

Martin said they were told it was a miniseries but believe there is “definitely more story to tell.” They also acknowledged the logistical challenges of continuing the plot realistically.

Which cast members want to return?

Key cast members, including Sarah Gadon, Toni Collette, Alyvia Alyn Lind, and Sydney Topliffe, have expressed interest in returning for a potential second season.

What would Season 2 be about?

A second season would likely explore the aftermath of Abbie’s escape and Evelyn’s collapse. It could also delve deeper into the lives of supporting characters at Tall Pines.

When will Netflix decide on renewal?

Netflix typically makes renewal decisions based on viewership numbers in the first few weeks after release. An announcement could come in the next month or two.

Trusted Sources

TV Insider, Variety