New Details Reveal How “It’s a Wonderful Life” Almost Had a Different Cast

The beloved holiday film “It’s a Wonderful Life” returns to television this Christmas Eve. NBC will broadcast the 1946 classic on Tuesday, December 24. The movie, starring James Stewart and Donna Reed, is a cherished tradition for millions.

While its message is timeless, the film’s own history is full of surprising twists. New insights reveal how close it came to having a completely different cast.

The Alternate Universe of Bedford Falls Casting

George Bailey is iconic, but James Stewart wasn’t the first choice. According to historical accounts, several major stars were considered. Both Henry Fonda and Cary Grant were in early discussions for the role. Stewart’s desperate performance on the bridge might have looked very different.

The role of Mary Bailey also saw many contenders. Director Frank Capra initially wanted actress Jean Arthur. When she was unavailable, Olivia de Havilland and Ginger Rogers were among those considered. Donna Reed was ultimately “borrowed” from another studio contract.

Even the villain, Mr. Potter, almost had another face. Actors like Vincent Price were reportedly discussed. Lionel Barrymore got the part and created a legendary screen miser.

From Forgotten Film to Holiday Staple

The movie was not an immediate hit. It actually lost money upon its initial release. Its path to becoming a Christmas classic was accidental.

A copyright lapse in the 1970s changed everything. The film entered the public domain. Television stations could then air it for free, leading to constant holiday broadcasts. This exposure cemented its status as a must-watch tradition.

Film historian Jeanine Basinger has analyzed its enduring appeal. She notes the universal theme of realizing one’s impact on a community. This message continues to resonate with new generations every year.

The story of “It’s a Wonderful Life” is now as much a part of holiday lore as the film itself. Its journey from box-office disappointment to beloved classic proves that some stories simply need time to find their rightful place in our hearts.

Info at your fingertips

When is “It’s a Wonderful Life” airing on TV this year?

NBC will broadcast the film on Christmas Eve, Tuesday, December 24. The airtime is set for 8 p.m. Eastern Time and 7 p.m. Central Time.

Who was almost cast instead of James Stewart?

Studio records show Henry Fonda and Cary Grant were both considered for the role of George Bailey. The director ultimately felt James Stewart was the perfect fit for the character’s everyman quality.

Why did the movie become a Christmas classic?

The film became a classic largely due to a copyright issue. When it entered the public domain in 1974, TV networks aired it extensively for free during the holidays, embedding it in seasonal tradition.

Was the movie a success when it was first released?

No, it was not. “It’s a Wonderful Life” was a financial disappointment during its initial theatrical run. It found its audience and acclaim only decades later through television.

What was the original story based on?

The film is based on a short story called “The Greatest Gift” by Philip Van Doren Stern. He originally printed it as a Christmas card for friends in 1943 before it was adapted for the screen.