Philadelphia Union vs NYCFC Playoff: A David vs Goliath Eastern Conference Semifinal

The Philadelphia Union host New York City FC in a high-stakes MLS Cup Playoff semifinal this Sunday. The match kicks off at 7:45 PM ET at Subaru Park. Philadelphia enters as the overwhelming favorite after a dominant regular season.

This single-elimination clash pits the league’s best team against a resilient underdog. NYCFC faces a monumental challenge, compounded by a critical injury to a star player.

Union’s Dominant Path to the Semifinals

The Philadelphia Union secured the 2025 Supporters’ Shield with the league’s best record. They then swiftly dispatched Chicago Fire in the first round. Their performance cemented their status as title contenders.

Forward Tai Baribo has been a revelation for the Union. He scored multiple goals against Chicago and recorded 16 goals in the regular season. His offensive surge provides a potent threat.

According to ESPN, the Union’s defense was the league’s best, allowing just 35 goals. This defensive solidity, combined with a near-perfect home record, makes them formidable opponents. They lost only once in 18 matches at Subaru Park.

NYCFC’s Uphill Battle and Key Absences

New York City FC arrives after a surprising road victory over Charlotte FC. Their underdog run now faces its toughest test. The team must overcome significant personnel losses.

Star forward Alonso Martínez suffered a knee injury on international duty. He scored 17 goals during the regular season. His absence creates a major void in NYCFC’s attack.

Midfielder Andrés Perea is also sidelined with an injury. These absences force head coach Pascal Jansen to find new solutions. The team’s depth will be critically tested against the league’s top side.

Tactical Analysis and Historical Context

This matchup hinges on Philadelphia’s structured defense versus NYCFC’s compromised attack. The Union’s system, led by defender Kai Wagner, is exceptionally disciplined. Wagner alone provided 11 assists this season.

Historically, these teams are evenly matched over 27 meetings. The Union have 13 wins to NYCFC’s 12. Recent form, however, heavily favors Philadelphia.

The Union have won four of the last six encounters between the clubs. This trend suggests a significant psychological and tactical advantage for the home side heading into the playoff pressure.

The Philadelphia Union vs NYCFC playoff showdown represents a classic clash of styles and circumstances, where the Union’s relentless consistency is pitted against NYCFC’s desperate resilience.

Info at your fingertips

What time is the Philadelphia Union vs NYCFC game?

The match starts at 7:45 PM Eastern Time on Sunday, November 23. It will be held at Subaru Park in Chester, Pennsylvania. The game is a single-elimination playoff fixture.

Who is injured for NYCFC?

NYCFC will be without top scorer Alonso Martínez due to a knee injury. Midfielder Andrés Perea is also unavailable. These absences significantly impact their offensive capabilities.

What is Philadelphia Union’s home record?

The Union have been nearly unbeatable at home this season. They recorded 17 wins and only 1 loss in 18 matches at Subaru Park. This formidable record gives them a massive advantage.

Who won the Supporters’ Shield?

The Philadelphia Union won the 2025 Supporters’ Shield. This award is given to the team with the best regular-season record. It secured them a top seed and home-field advantage in the playoffs.

What are the odds for the game?

Sportsbooks heavily favor the Philadelphia Union with odds around -125. NYCFC are significant underdogs at approximately +320. This reflects the Union’s dominant season and home-field advantage.