Property Brothers Drew and Jonathan Scott Reveal the One House They Refused to Renovate

HGTV stars Drew and Jonathan Scott have transformed hundreds of homes. But one property was too dangerous to fix. The twins recently shared this unique story with Realtor.com.They explained this happened during their original show format. Homebuyers were determined to purchase a specific problematic house. The brothers had to make a tough professional call.

The Structural Nightmare That Couldn’t Be Saved

The problematic house was built on an old landfill. Jonathan Scott stated the foundation was failing. The entire structure was actively sinking into the ground.This caused severe structural damage throughout. The brothers immediately warned the potential buyers. They advised them firmly not to purchase the home.The clients bought the house anyway. They then proposed a cheap fix instead of proper repairs. Their plan involved simply leveling the uneven floors.This would have left ceilings dangerously low. Jonathan estimated some rooms would have only 6.5-foot ceilings. The solution was both impractical and unsafe.The homeowners also wanted to proceed without permits. Jonathan confirmed this would have been illegal. The Scotts refused to participate in an unlawful project.They ultimately walked away from the renovation. This decision led them to cancel the entire episode. It remains the only scrapped episode in over 650 shows.

Behind the Scenes of a Twin Partnership

The brothers also addressed a past pay disparity issue. Jonathan once earned more due to heavier filming demands. He spent triple the time on-site during renovations.He discussed this openly on SiriusXM’s Andy Cohen Live. Jonathan recalled asking if his larger workload justified higher pay. The twins have since resolved this early business rift.Drew clarified their off-camera roles are more balanced. Both brothers contribute to construction and real estate work. They have expanded far beyond television into a large home brand.Their business now includes thousands of products. They also manage a multi-family real estate portfolio. Their partnership remains strong after fifteen years on air.

Fortnite’s Epic 2025 Collabs: From Godzilla to Bleach, Ranking the Biggest Crossovers

The Property Brothers’ strict ethics and expertise saved them from a legal disaster. Their story highlights the critical importance of proper permits and structural integrity in any renovation project.

A quick knowledge drop for you

Q1: Why did the Property Brothers refuse to renovate the house?

The house was built on an old landfill and was sinking. It had massive, irreversible structural problems. The owners also wanted to work without proper permits, which is illegal.

Q2: What happened to the episode featuring that house?

It is the only episode they ever cancelled. They filmed part of it but stopped production entirely. This was to avoid being involved in an illegal renovation project.

Q3: Was there ever tension between Drew and Jonathan over pay?

Yes, Jonathan once brought up a pay disparity due to his longer filming hours. This was early in their career. They have since resolved the issue amicably.

Q4: What do the Scott brothers do outside of their HGTV shows?

They run a large home brand with thousands of products. They also manage a significant multi-family real estate investment portfolio. Their business reach extends far beyond television.

Q5: How many shows have the Property Brothers filmed?

They have completed over 650 episodes across their various series. The cancelled project is the single exception in their entire filming history. Their consistency is a hallmark of their brand.

Trusted Sources: Realtor.com, SiriusXM Andy Cohen Live, HGTV.