Robin Hood Season 1 Episode 5 Recap: Tragic Twist Shakes Sheriff’s Family

The latest episode of the MGM+ series delivered a shocking and emotional blow. “Go Back to Them,” which aired on November 23, 2025, ended with an accidental shooting that changes everything. This pivotal moment turns the Sheriff’s political crusade into a deeply personal war.

Robert Locksley’s rebellion faces its greatest threat yet from a unified enemy. The episode masterfully blends intense action with character-driven drama, setting a new tone for the season.

A Deepening Conflict and a Fateful Decision

The Sheriff of Nottingham, enraged by the attack on the Bishop’s convoy, intensifies his manhunt. He joins forces with the powerful Earls of Leicester and Warwick to crush the uprising. Their combined forces corner Robert’s band near Stafford’s Mill, creating an inescapable situation.

Fearing for his men’s lives, Robert makes a heartbreaking choice. He officially disbands the Merry Men, ordering them to scatter and hide. He instructs them to bury their stolen wealth under a great oak for safekeeping, hoping this will protect them.

The High Cost of Rebellion and an Unplanned Reunion

The plan to separate quickly falls apart. Key allies, including the Miller siblings, are captured and tortured by the Sheriff’s forces. They are sentenced to public execution at the gallows in Nottingham, forcing Robert to act.

He has no choice but to regroup his scattered followers for a rescue mission. The reunited band, now including the skilled fighter Isabel, devises a complex plan involving disguises, diversions, and precise archery to save their friends.

A Rescue Mission With Catastrophic Consequences

The rescue operation is a tense, multi-pronged assault. Friar Tuck and Spragart pose as priests to get close to the gallows. Meanwhile, Little John creates chaos by setting a nearby tavern ablaze.

Robert provides covering fire from the shadows with his longbow. The team successfully frees the prisoners and escapes through the castle gates with help from an inside ally. However, the victory is short-lived and comes at a terrible price.

The Accidental Shot That Changes Everything

In the final moments, Robert spots the Sheriff fleeing the scene. He takes aim with his bow, determined to end the conflict. But as he releases the arrow, the Sheriff’s daughter, Priscilla, steps directly into its path.

The arrow strikes her. This single, unintentional act transforms the entire nature of the conflict. The Sheriff’s motivation shifts instantly from enforcing royal law to seeking pure, unadulterated vengeance for his wounded child.

Setting the Stage for a Personal War

This tragedy marks a definitive turning point in the series. The political struggle over taxes and justice is now overshadowed by a raw, emotional feud. Robert must grapple with the heavy moral consequences of his actions, even accidental ones.

Meanwhile, Marian continues her dangerous work as a spy in Queen Eleanor’s court. Her mission to gather intelligence on the Sheriff is now complicated by this new, deeply personal vendetta that will undoubtedly draw her in.

The accidental shooting of Priscilla in Robin Hood Season 1 Episode 5 elevates the stakes from a rebellion to a deeply personal war, promising a brutal and emotionally charged path forward for all characters involved.

Dropping this nugget your way

Did Robin Hood mean to shoot Priscilla?

No, the shooting was a tragic accident. Robert’s arrow was intended for the Sheriff of Nottingham. Priscilla moved into the arrow’s path at the last second, completely changing the context of the conflict.

Why did Robert tell the Merry Men to split up?

He believed disbanding was the only way to keep them safe from the Sheriff’s expanding search parties. He hoped that by hiding separately, they could avoid capture and preserve their rebellion for another day.

Who are the new allies in this episode?

Isabel, a cousin to the captured Miller siblings, joins the fight. The outlaws also receive crucial help from Milange, a former castle servant who aids their escape from Nottingham.

What is Marian’s role in Queen Eleanor’s court?

Marian is acting as a spy for the Queen. Her primary task is to gather intelligence on the Sheriff’s political maneuvers and ensure the succession of Prince Richard to the throne.

Where can I watch this episode?

“Go Back to Them” is available for streaming on MGM+. New episodes of the series are released weekly for subscribers to the platform.