Scarlett Johansson’s Directorial Debut “Eleanor the Great” Premieres to Mixed Reactions

Scarlett Johansson’s first feature film as a director, “Eleanor the Great,” arrives in theaters this Friday. The movie stars Academy Award nominee June Squibb as a nonagenarian navigating grief and friendship. According to The Associated Press, the film presents a poignant story that is complicated by a controversial plot device.

The film explores deep themes of loss and connection. However, its central narrative choice has divided early critics.

June Squibb Anchors a Story of Late-Life New Beginnings

June Squibb plays Eleanor, a woman in her nineties forced to start over. After the death of her best friend Bessie, she moves from Florida to New York City. She moves in with her daughter and grandson.

Eleanor struggles with loneliness in her new environment. Her family seems focused on moving her to assisted living. This isolation leads her to seek companionship in unexpected places.

The script, by Tory Kamen, initially establishes a touching dynamic. Early scenes show Eleanor and Bessie’s joyful life together. Their friendship is portrayed with warmth and authenticity.

A Controversial Lie Drives the Plot Forward

Eleanor finds herself at a local Jewish Community Center. She is mistakenly identified as a Holocaust survivor. Instead of correcting the error, she leans into the lie.

This fabrication forms an unlikely bond with a journalism student named Nina. Nina, grieving her own mother’s death, finds solace in Eleanor’s company. Their friendship becomes the heart of the film.

The lie, however, quickly spirals beyond Eleanor’s control. It attracts media attention, leading to a public speaking event. The situation builds toward an inevitable and painful confrontation.

This narrative choice has been cited by reviewers as the film’s main weakness. The Associated Press notes the contrivance often overshadows the stronger elements of character study.

Performances Shine Despite Script Flaws

Critics universally praise the performances of the lead actors. June Squibb’s portrayal of Eleanor is described as moving and nuanced. Her ability to convey deep emotion anchors the entire film.

Opposite her, newcomer Thuso Keledy is commended for her role as Nina. Their on-screen chemistry provides the story’s most genuine moments. Johansson’s direction wisely focuses on these powerful performances.

The film is rated PG-13 for thematic elements and language. Its runtime is a concise 98 minutes. While the plot may stumble, the acting is a significant draw for audiences.

“Eleanor the Great” showcases a stellar performance from June Squibb. The film’s impactful themes of friendship and grief are sometimes undermined by its central plot device. Ultimately, the powerful acting makes it a noteworthy, if flawed, directorial debut for Scarlett Johansson.

Dropping this nugget your way

What is the main criticism of “Eleanor the Great”?

The primary criticism involves the central plot device. Eleanor pretends to be a Holocaust survivor to make friends. Many reviewers find this narrative choice unnecessary and hard to watch.

Who stars in the movie alongside June Squibb?

Thuso Keledy plays Nina, a journalism student who befriends Eleanor. The cast also includes actors portraying Eleanor’s daughter and grandson. Their performances have been well-received by critics.

Is this Scarlett Johansson’s first time directing?

Yes, “Eleanor the Great” is Scarlett Johansson’s feature-length directorial debut. She has previously directed short films. Her direction here is noted for its focus on character performance.

What is the movie’s rating and runtime?

The film is rated PG-13 by the Motion Picture Association. This is for some language and thematic elements. It runs for approximately 98 minutes.

Where does the story of “Eleanor the Great” take place?

The story begins in Florida before moving to New York City. Eleanor relocates after her best friend passes away. The setting of New York emphasizes her isolation and search for new connections.