Shane Black’s Play Dirty Review: A Gritty Heist with Uneven Payoff

Director Shane Black returns with a new action-comedy, “Play Dirty,” now streaming on Amazon Prime. The film stars Mark Wahlberg as career criminal Parker in an adaptation of Donald E. Westlake’s novels. This marks Black’s first major genre film since “The Nice Guys,” blending his signature wit with high-stakes heist action.

According to Reuters, the project was initially developed with Robert Downey Jr. attached. The final cast includes LaKeith Stanfield and Rosa Salazar, who bring significant energy to the ensemble. The plot follows a classic revenge and redemption arc set against a chaotic criminal underworld.

Plot and Performance Analysis

The story begins with a botched robbery. Parker is betrayed by his new accomplice, Zen, played by Rosa Salazar. She steals the loot and disappears, setting the stage for a larger, more dangerous scheme.

Parker is forced to assemble a new team. This includes LaKeith Stanfield’s charismatic Grofield. Their target is a priceless artifact tied to a corrupt dictator. The mission involves multiple double-crosses and a final confrontation on New Year’s Eve.

Mark Wahlberg delivers a physically capable performance. However, his portrayal lacks the dangerous charisma the Parker role demands. This is particularly noticeable alongside Stanfield’s scene-stealing presence. Salazar, meanwhile, provides a fiery and compelling counterpoint to Wahlberg’s stoic lead.

Stylistic Successes and Shortcomings

Shane Black’s directorial style is evident throughout. The film features his trademark snappy dialogue and chaotic action set pieces. The opening horse-track robbery is destructively fun and sets a strong tone.

Yet the film struggles with pacing and focus. Its nearly two-hour runtime feels overstuffed with subplots. Endless betrayals dilute the core narrative’s impact. Some action sequences suffer from unconvincing visual effects, a noted issue from its Australian production.

The supporting cast adds valuable comedic relief. Keegan-Michael Key and Claire Lovering provide a bickering dynamic that lands well. Despite these bright spots, the film never fully escapes the feel of a standard streaming action-comedy, failing to match the polish of Black’s earlier cinematic triumphs.

“Play Dirty” offers a mixed bag of sharp wit and convoluted plotting. While it delivers moments of genuine entertainment, the film’s uneven execution and Wahlberg’s miscasting prevent it from becoming a standout heist classic. The result is a watchable, if forgettable, addition to the genre on Amazon Prime.

Dropping this nugget your way-

Where can I watch Play Dirty?

“Play Dirty” is available exclusively on Amazon Prime Video. It began streaming in early October. You need an active subscription to view it.

Is Play Dirty based on a book?

Yes, the film is based on the Parker novel series by Donald E. Westlake. The author wrote the books under the pseudonym Richard Stark. This is not the first adaptation of the character.

Who stars in the movie alongside Mark Wahlberg?

The main cast includes LaKeith Stanfield and Rosa Salazar. Keegan-Michael Key and Tony Shalhoub also feature in supporting roles. The ensemble is a key strength of the film.

How long is the Play Dirty movie?

The film has a runtime of approximately 120 minutes. Some critics note this length contributes to a bloated feel. The pacing is a point of discussion in several reviews.

How does it compare to other Shane Black films?

It shares DNA with “The Nice Guys” in its comedic tone. However, it generally ranks below his classic works like “Lethal Weapon.” The film’s reception has been more muted than for his peak-era projects.