Survivor Cast Reveals Their Picks for the Best Survivor Season Ever

The debate over the best season of “Survivor” is a classic pastime for fans. Now, the castaways from the currently airing “Survivor 49” are joining the conversation. In a new interview with Entertainment Weekly, the players revealed their all-time favorite seasons, offering a unique perspective from those who have lived the game.

Their choices span the show’s entire 25-year history, from the very first outing to recent chapters. This provides a fascinating look at what resonates with people who have actually faced the elements and the social dynamics on the island.

Old-School Classics and Modern Favorites Split the Vote

The cast’s selections show a clear divide between classic and modern eras. Several players pointed to foundational seasons as their top picks. Annie Davis chose the inaugural “Survivor: Borneo” for its groundbreaking impact. She stated it blew the doors off what reality TV could be.

Jeremiah Ing selected “Survivor: The Australian Outback,” citing nostalgic memories of watching it with his father. Steven Ramm picked “Survivor: Pearl Islands” for its comforting, old-school gameplay and the introduction of fan-favorite Rupert Boneham. These choices highlight the enduring power of the show’s early years.

Iconic Gameplay and Memorable Moments Seal the Deal

For other players, specific strategic moves and memorable characters defined the best season. A full four castaways—Kristina Mills, Nicole Mazullo, Nate Moore, and Jawan Pitts—unanimously selected “Survivor: Cagayan” as the peak. They praised its perfect casting, surprising blindsides, and the legendary gameplay of winner Tony Vlachos.

Meanwhile, two castaways, Savannah Louie and Sophie Segreti, championed the all-star “Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains.” They cited its nostalgic value and the intense fire every contestant brought to the game. According to Entertainment Weekly, this season is often considered the show’s competitive pinnacle.

The search for the single best “Survivor” season continues with no definitive answer. This new insight from the “Survivor 49” cast proves that the best season is ultimately a matter of personal taste and what first captures a fan’s heart.

Info at your fingertips

Which ‘Survivor’ season did the most cast members choose?

Four separate castaways from “Survivor 49” selected “Survivor: Cagayan” as their favorite. They praised its nearly perfect casting, exciting twists, and unpredictable gameplay that hooked viewers from the start.

Did any players choose a recent season as their favorite?

Yes, several players showed love for the “new era” of the show. Michelle “MC” Chukwujekwu chose “Survivor 44,” while Sage Ahrens-Nichols and Jake Latimer both selected the most recent completed season, “Survivor 47.”

What was the most surprising pick from the cast?

Matt Williams’ choice of “Survivor: Edge of Extinction” was a surprise to many fans. He defended the controversial season, praising winner Chris Underwood for his unique comeback victory.

Which classic season was mentioned multiple times?

“Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains” was a standout for two cast members. They highlighted its all-star cast and the high level of gameplay as reasons for its top-tier status.

Why did a player choose ‘Survivor: Cook Islands’?

Alex Moore called his choice of “Survivor: Cook Islands” controversial but loved its iconic players and memorable moments. He specifically mentioned the rivalry between Ozzy Lusth and Yul Kwon.