The Queen of Versailles Musical Divides Broadway Critics Following 2025 Premiere

A new Broadway musical opened to intense scrutiny on November 9, 2025. “The Queen of Versailles” stars Kristin Chenoweth at the St. James Theatre. The production is based on Lauren Greenfield’s 2012 documentary.

Critics delivered sharply divided opinions. Many praised Chenoweth’s performance. Yet they heavily criticized the show’s overall execution and length.

Critical Reception Highlights Stellar Cast, Flawed Material

Reviews from major outlets were largely negative. Variety described the show as an “overly ambitious slog.” The publication argued Broadway was the wrong medium for this story.

The Washington Post said the musical exemplifies the excess it tries to satirize. Theatrely called it “mostly dull.” Entertainment Weekly found the treatment “superficial.”

These critiques consistently highlighted one positive. Kristin Chenoweth’s commanding performance received universal acclaim. Her portrayal of socialite Jackie Siegel was called brilliant and sympathetic.

Production Challenges and Audience Impact

The show runs two hours and forty minutes. Many critics noted it drags significantly by Act Two. Stephen Schwartz’s music was largely deemed forgettable.

Only “Caviar Dreams” stood out as a stronger number. The scenic design by Dane Laffrey earned praise for its seamless transitions. Costumes by Christian Cowan effectively established the “new money” aesthetic.

Supporting cast members delivered powerhouse vocals. F. Murray Abraham provided perfect crotchety charm as David Siegel. Despite these strengths, the fundamental material struggled to connect.

“The Queen of Versailles” faces an uncertain future on Broadway following its mixed critical reception. The production demonstrates that even a superstar performance cannot always overcome foundational storytelling issues. Theatergoers must decide for themselves whether Chenoweth’s brilliance outweighs the show’s noted flaws.

Thought you’d like to know-

What is The Queen of Versailles musical about?

It is based on the 2012 documentary about billionaire couple Jackie and David Siegel. The story follows their quest to build America’s largest single-family home. It examines themes of wealth, ambition, and the 2008 financial crisis.

Who stars in the Broadway production?

Kristin Chenoweth headlines as socialite Jackie Siegel. F. Murray Abraham plays her husband, David Siegel. The cast includes Nina White and Tatum Grace Hopkins in supporting roles.

How long is the show’s runtime?

The musical runs approximately 2 hours and 40 minutes including intermission. Many critics found this length excessive. Some suggested trimming would improve pacing dramatically.

What are the main criticisms?

Critics cite tonal inconsistency and forgettable music as primary issues. The show struggles to balance satire with sincere drama. The source material’s translation to musical theater was questioned.

Is it worth seeing despite reviews?

Fans of Kristin Chenoweth may find her performance alone worthwhile. The production design and supporting cast are strong. Those seeking cohesive storytelling might reconsider.

Who composed the music and lyrics?

Stephen Schwartz, known for Wicked and Godspell, created the score. Lindsey Ferrentino wrote the book. Michael Arden, a Tony Award winner, directed the production.