The chilling case of Lucy Letby – convicted of murdering seven infants and attempting to kill six others at a UK hospital – continues to haunt public consciousness. Now, a provocative new documentary, Lucy Letby: Who to Believe?, reignites debate over the evidence that sealed her fate. Available for free streaming globally, this BBC film dissects the conflicting narratives surrounding Britain’s most notorious neonatal nurse, challenging viewers to scrutinize the trial that sentenced her to life imprisonment.

How Can International Viewers Access the Lucy Letby Documentary?

Lucy Letby: Who to Believe? streams exclusively on BBC iPlayer, though geographic restrictions typically block access outside the UK. Audiences worldwide can bypass this barrier using a VPN (Virtual Private Network). Simply connect your VPN to a UK server, sign into BBC iPlayer, and stream the documentary instantly. This method also works for ITVX’s earlier documentary, Lucy Letby: Beyond Reasonable Doubt?, which similarly examines lingering questions about forensic evidence and medical testimony.

The investigation into Letby began after a spike in infant deaths at Chester’s Countess of Chester Hospital between 2015-2016. Prosecutors alleged she injected newborns with air or insulin, leading to her 2022 trial and 2023 whole-life sentence. Yet, as the BBC documentary reveals, international medical experts contest the prosecution’s evidence, arguing neonatal collapses could stem from natural causes rather than foul play. With over 250 pages of trial transcripts analyzed, the film underscores how ambiguous medical data fueled polarizing interpretations – a reality forcing global audiences to confront uncomfortable uncertainties in high-stakes jurisprudence.

What Critical Questions Does the Documentary Explore?

Who to Believe? avoids sensationalism, methodically dissecting trial contradictions through interviews with legal analysts and independent specialists. Reporter Judith Moritz investigates why pediatrician Dr. Dewi Evans, the prosecution’s lead expert, concluded Letby deliberately harmed babies – while defense witnesses cited understaffing and hospital failures as plausible factors. The film highlights how identical medical notes fueled opposing conclusions: one side saw calculated malice; the other saw systemic neglect.

As noted in the official BBC synopsis, the documentary examines why “complex medical evidence” remains fiercely contested. Recent reports from The Guardian (August 2024) detail petitions by scientists urging case reinvestigation, citing statistical flaws in linking Letby to all incidents. Yet Cheshire Police maintain evidence is “overwhelming,” with detectives pursuing additional charges. This clash epitomizes a broader crisis in healthcare trust – a theme Who to Believe? explores through harrowing parent testimonies juxtaposed with forensic counterarguments.

The documentary compels viewers to weigh circumstantial patterns against reasonable doubt. As Letby’s appeals unfold, her case exposes how justice navigates ambiguity – and why global audiences remain captivated by truths still shrouded in darkness.

Must Know

Q: Is the Lucy Letby documentary available without a VPN?
A: Only UK residents can stream it directly on BBC iPlayer. International viewers require a VPN set to a UK location to access the platform legally.

Q: What evidence convicted Lucy Letby?
A: Prosecutors presented patterns of infant collapses during her shifts, insulin poisoning proof, and handwritten confessions. Defense teams argued coincidental timing and inadequate hospital resources (BBC News, 2023).

Q: Are experts disputing the verdict?
A: Yes. Over 200 scientists petitioned for case review, criticizing statistical methods used to establish guilt (Science Journal, 2024).

Q: How long is the documentary?
A: Who to Believe? runs for 60 minutes, synthesizing trial footage, expert interviews, and hospital records.

Q: Can I watch both documentaries?
A: Absolutely. Use a VPN for BBC iPlayer (Who to Believe?) and ITVX (Beyond Reasonable Doubt?) to compare their analyses.

Q: Did Lucy Letby confess?
A: Letby wrote “I killed them” in a note, but claimed it reflected mental anguish, not admission (Court testimony, 2022).