Why Prince Andrew Remains in the Royal Line of Succession After Losing His Titles

King Charles III has formally stripped his brother, Prince Andrew, of his royal titles and styles. The move comes amid ongoing controversy surrounding Andrew’s association with the late financier and convicted sex offender, Jeffrey Epstein. Despite this severe censure, Andrew remains eighth in line to the British throne.

This decision effectively ends Andrew’s public life as a working royal. According to a statement from Buckingham Palace, the action was necessary despite Andrew’s continued denial of the allegations against him.

The Legal Hurdles Preventing Removal from Succession

Removing Prince Andrew from the line of succession is an incredibly complex legal process. It is not a decision the King can make unilaterally. The procedure is governed by centuries-old laws and international agreements.

The United Kingdom would need to pass a new act of Parliament. This is a lengthy and resource-intensive undertaking. The last major change, the Succession to the Crown Act of 2013, took two years of negotiations to finalize.

Furthermore, all 14 other Commonwealth realms must consent to the change. This includes countries like Canada, Australia, and Jamaica. The requirement stems from the Statute of Westminster of 1931, which solidified the equality of these nations.

Historical Precedents and the Current Line of Succession

History shows that royals can leave the line of succession, but through different means. King Edward VIII abdicated the throne in 1936 to marry Wallis Simpson. This voluntary act removed him and his descendants from the line.

Prince Michael of Kent forfeited his place when he married a Catholic in 1978. However, he was later reinstated after the 2013 Act removed the ban on marrying Catholics. Andrew’s situation is distinct because it involves involuntary removal due to scandal.

The current line of succession ahead of Andrew is clear. Prince William is first, followed by his three children: George, Charlotte, and Louis. Prince Harry and his two children, Archie and Lilibet, complete the list of the seven individuals preceding Andrew.

This situation underscores the immense difficulty in altering the established line of succession. The fact that Prince Andrew remains a potential heir highlights the rigid constitutional framework governing the monarchy, even in the face of profound scandal.

Info at your fingertips

Why did Prince Andrew lose his royal titles?

King Charles III stripped Andrew of his titles due to the ongoing scandal and allegations linked to his friendship with Jeffrey Epstein. Buckingham Palace stated the move was necessary to protect the monarchy’s reputation.

Can Prince Andrew ever return to royal duties?

Most royal experts believe his return is highly unlikely. One analyst told the BBC that this action “closes the door permanently on any hopes he may have had to one day return to royal life.”

Who is now directly in line for the throne after Prince Andrew?

Prince Andrew is eighth in line. He is preceded by Prince William, Prince George, Princess Charlotte, Prince Louis, Prince Harry, Prince Archie, and Princess Lilibet.

Has a royal ever been removed from the line of succession before?

Yes, but not through a forced removal like this. Royals have lost their place through abdication, like King Edward VIII, or through marriage to a Catholic, as was the law before 2013.

What is Prince Andrew’s legal name now?

He is now formally known as Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor. He no longer uses the style “His Royal Highness” or the title Duke of York.