Why Trading Jazz Chisholm for Freddy Peralta is a Flawed Yankees Gamble

The New York Yankees are actively seeking a frontline starting pitcher this offseason. A recent trade proposal suggests sending All-Star infielder Jazz Chisholm to Milwaukee for ace Freddy Peralta. This one-for-one swap is gaining attention but appears deeply flawed for the Yankees.

According to analysis from Bleacher Report, the Brewers’ motivation would be Chisholm’s power. However, this creates a major hole in New York’s lineup. The Yankees have not confirmed any such deal is under discussion.

The Brewers’ Needs Don’t Match the Yankees’ Weakness

The proposed trade logic is questionable. Bleacher Report’s Zachary D. Rymer noted the Brewers’ need for more home runs. Their offense lacked power during the 2025 NLCS.

Yet, Milwaukee already has a strong second baseman in Brice Turang. Chisholm would likely have to switch positions. The Yankees, conversely, would be left with a glaring vacancy at second base.

Their infield already faces uncertainty at shortstop. Trading a core player for an area of lesser need for the acquiring team is risky business. It does not solve a clear problem for either club.

Chisholm’s Value to New York is Simply Too High

Jazz Chisholm provided immense value for the Yankees in 2025. He was a rare 30-30 player, hitting 31 homers and stealing 31 bases. His defense was also elite, ranking in the 88th percentile with 5 Outs Above Average.

Losing that production would weaken an infield already short on proven power. First baseman Ben Rice is a notable exception. The team would struggle to replace Chisholm’s unique skill set.

Other commentators have speculated about clubhouse fit as a trade motive. The organization has not addressed these theories. On pure performance, trading Chisholm creates a bigger problem than it solves.

The Yankees’ search for pitching is understandable, but sacrificing Jazz Chisholm for Freddy Peralta is not the answer. His all-star production is too vital to a lineup with other holes, making this proposed trade a losing move for New York.

Thought you’d like to know

Why would the Yankees consider trading Jazz Chisholm?

Analysts suggest the Yankees may seek a frontline starting pitcher. Some speculate clubhouse dynamics could also be a factor, though the team has not confirmed this.

What did Chisholm achieve for the Yankees in 2025?

He had a 30-30 season with 31 home runs and 31 stolen bases. Defensively, he recorded 5 Outs Above Average, placing him among the league’s top defenders.

Why might the Brewers want Jazz Chisholm?

Bleacher Report analysis states the Brewers need more home run power. Chisholm’s bat would address an offensive weakness they showed in the playoffs.

Who would play second base for the Yankees if Chisholm is traded?

This is the central flaw of the proposal. The Yankees have no clear internal replacement, creating a significant new hole in their infield defense and lineup.

Are the Yankees pursuing other starting pitchers?

Yes. The Yankees are considered finalists for Japanese pitcher Tatsuya Imai. They are actively exploring multiple avenues to upgrade their rotation.