Yankees Offseason Stalls As Boras Strategy Threatens Key Free Agent Targets

The New York Yankees’ quiet winter has taken a concerning turn. New reports suggest super-agent Scott Boras could delay deals for his clients, including top Yankees target Cody Bellinger. This waiting game risks derailing the team’s entire offseason strategy and could leave them empty-handed.

According to insights from The Athletic and MLB.com, Boras may wait for outfielder Kyle Tucker to sign first. This creates a major problem for the Yankees, who see Bellinger as a priority. The longer this stalemate continues, the more their plans unravel.

Backup Plans Look Shaky as Market Tightens

If the Yankees miss on both Bellinger and Tucker, their internal options are risky. The spotlight would fall on prospects Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones. Neither player is considered a sure thing for the 2025 season.

Dominguez’s defense in left field has been statistically poor. Jones struggles with a high strikeout rate in the minors. While the organization believes in their talent, relying on them now is a major gamble. General Manager Brian Cashman has acknowledged they may get a chance, but fans expect proven stars.

This puts the Yankees in a difficult position. Their focus could shift to the trade market. Speculation suggests they might trade from their prospect depth or even consider moving infielder Jazz Chisholm Jr. to acquire a powerful bat.

Alternatively, they could pivot to signing a free agent pitcher like Tatsuya Imai and trade for an outfielder. However, the market for impact hitters is shrinking fast. Missing their top targets would be a significant setback.

The New York Yankees offseason is at a critical juncture. Their pursuit of Cody Bellinger is caught in a high-stakes agent strategy that could backfire. The team must quickly develop a credible alternative plan or risk facing fan disappointment before spring training even begins.

Info at your fingertips

Who is Scott Boras and why does he matter?

Scott Boras is a powerful sports agent representing many top MLB free agents. His negotiation tactics often involve waiting for the market to set a price, which can delay signings for teams like the Yankees who want his clients.

Why do the Yankees want Cody Bellinger back?

Bellinger had an excellent 2025 season with the Yankees, providing strong offense and elite defense. Losing him would create a major hole in their lineup and outfield defense that is hard to fill.

What are the Yankees’ main backup options?

Internally, they could use prospects Jasson Dominguez or Spencer Jones. Externally, they may explore trades, possibly involving their own prospects or current major league players like Jazz Chisholm Jr., to acquire a bat.

How does Kyle Tucker affect the Yankees’ plans?

Tucker is another elite outfielder on the market. Reports suggest agent Scott Boras may want Tucker’s contract to set the market value before finalizing a deal for his client, Cody Bellinger, putting the Yankees in a bind.

When do the Yankees need to make a move?

Time is becoming a factor. As other free agents sign, the available options diminish. The Yankees likely want their major roster moves settled before the start of spring training in February.